The bottom of the wheel can only spin upwards. But sometimes the buggy hits a ditch and the wheel goes off flying.
SPARKSOFDARKNESS
Written circa 2019An earlier work, not a statement of my current views.
© 2026 Benjamin Gabbai. All rights reserved.
Read and pause.Introduction
I
The purpose of this collection is not to present you with facts, rather with doors to new rooms of thought. An aphorism is rarely an adequate medium to prove a proposition, and should not be expected to. In fact, an aphorism is equally powerful when it is clearly false, as some of these are. It is up to the reader to discern between the true and the false aphorisms, or particular aspects of an aphorism.
This is a radical departure from conventional education (and I see this book as an educational book, just as any good work of literature is). The general idea of a typical non-fiction book is to force the opinions of the writer down the throat of the reader's mind via proofs, anecdotes, numbers, and whatever other weapon that can be reached. This is not the way this book has been written. Although not in the typical style, the telos here is more akin to good fiction, the type that gets you to think.
Hence, this collection is here to provoke thought. I really do not want to convince you of anything. I repeat: I want you to think. I am grateful to authors who have inspired me to sit long hours in contemplation, often on the question of whether a topic is even of importance, before investigating the truth of the claims. They have nourished my soul and made be greater than I was. In Sparks of Darkness, I hope and pray I can do the same for others.
Please read these with your highest level of intellectual vigor. Read and pause. Sound out your thoughts or have a notebook ready for your notes. Please do not rapidly read, as I can promise you that this will only be a waste of your time. Some books have utility like that. This one does not.
As will probably be noticed, there are many conflicting aphorisms. I do not deny this, nor do I claim that this was always intentional. These aphorisms were written over a long span of time, and as man is dynamic, there are naturally going to be changes in my thought.
If I was editing a philosophical treatise that claimed truth, I would certainly make sure that my book was consistent. But I see no aim in that. Rather, I repeat a third time, and therefore it is true, my goal is to provoke thought in the reader and nurture their mind with food. Hence, my criteria during the editing process was whether the aphorism was worth meditation. Opposing aspects on the same topic naturally both passed, and unless I felt the aphorisms did not each contribute an additional facet.
II
The inspiration for writing began in my first week in teacher's college. I quickly recognized that in order to avoid killing others around me or myself I would need some sort of activity while hearing stupid things said by stupid people. Having recently read Nassim Taleb's Bed of Procrustes, I began writing aphorisms for myself on scraps of paper. After some time, I collected these papers and typed them on a computer. I also began writing poetry as well, which will G-d willing be released as a part of a larger collection.
When I wrote I never had the intention of publishing, but as I would review what I wrote, and felt little lightning bolts of insight flash, I thought that perhaps others would appreciate these as well. When some friends showed interest and complimented my writing, I decided to go full throttle, and now you hold the book in your hands. Thank you Nathan V and Rhys C.
III
The title Sparks of Darkness, besides being catchy as hell, also manifests what I believe we are lacking today. There is an abundance of everything, and we are blinded by light. It is time we learn to forget, to learn to sit and do nothing. It is time progressing stopped, and reflection awakened.
(Sparks of Darkness)
The flame ablaze,
Men in a daze,
Blinded by the light.
The words he spoke
Spread black smoke,
Revealed our sense of sight.
A fire of black
To burn in attack
The trivial lies of fashion.
Glorious praise
In love of the haze
Our hero spread with passion.
Chronus
The Dominion of Time
Imagine if Job didn’t lose his family and riches, rather began his career poor, alone and righteous? This lonely one is plagued with boils of which he complains. Then G-d rewards him with family and riches.
Why does losing something hurt more than not having it?
Dynamics. Dynamics. Dynamics.
Being sick is like being half alive. And I already know from experience that when I get better I will only appreciate my health for about ten minutes.
With fever, one day in bed can save ten after.
It is an insult to the neomaniacs to be old. But to the classicists, it is a privilege and honor.
Remember: some of today’s culture will be remembered the way we remember the ‘Chicken Dance’ fad, and some will be remembered like Beethoven’s 5th.
A thought can still be original, even if others have had it before.
The uncertainty principle of human judgments: Until action there is good and bad, but after, we become one-sided.
On days of banality I admire noble autonomy.
On days of hate I admire kindness.
Time is a function of change in things other than time.
The title ‘life’ is a function of time and space. A stone and a spinach are the same in an instant. And a city is alive in some ways if you step back far enough.
The ‘objective’ time is based on the similarities of all humans. We all feel the change of the sun, our heartbeat.
Time exists because we are not always in the present. Time is the child of memories and narrative.
The Serpent
The Spoken Word
To shorten a word’s syllables is to multiply its frequency.
To multiply a word’s frequency is likely to also shorten its syllables.
People are like balloons. With tact be careful not to pop them, with wisdom see they are full of air.
Myself included.
Irony is the art of communicating only to the intelligent.
The louder you must speak to be heard, the less they want to hear you.
Therefore- listen to your volume.
How can one pride themselves with an open mind, and yet not converse with those minds closed.
Talking to some people is like talking to a simple algorithm, where the response can be predicted with a little induction.
Polemics is philosophy in a social world, and nothing to be ashamed of.
Instructions for fools: Speak. Pretend to listen. Repeat.
Why are people offended when others are wrong?
And why are people offended when others think they are?
Conversing with an encyclopedia would be interesting if not for the fact that encyclopedias prefer to lecture.
I lose my ability to converse with people on topics I have thought about independently. They think that we are sharing opinions. But my thoughts are the children of hours of meditation, and theirs were born with their speech in the best case.
If they would inquire with me than there could be a dialogue. My speech patterns and mindset must be blocking such an option.
Most of life is communication. When shall we do? Or is communication doing?
Probably depends how ya do it.
If only things said at funerals were spoken to the living.
EA Poe- to praise the self evident is to insult. Imagine calling a middle aged person mature.
If you would not speak of them like this in front of their mother, you should not say it at all.
If you would say it front of their mother, you’re a jerk!
When we attempt to embarrass others, we most likely are just embarrassing ourselves.
I’ve lost many arguments because I or the argument was labeled with the title of an outside group. Is it my fault that they got it right?
What matters what you say? It matters what I hear.
What matters what I say? It matters what you hear.
You’ve thought about it for x minutes of your life- yet spoken of it at least x + y.
Small talk is a trivialization of speech.
To forbid discussion on a conviction is to reveal that your inner sense of worth stands not on truth, but on opinion.
The tone of voice will always bend the words. The reverse?
A riddle is a question that you know the answer to, but ask anyway just to torment a friend.
“Well… that was a blatant lie.”
“Are you calling me a liar?”
No, rather a good conversationalist, and a great storyteller.
If you are offended by being described honestly for what you do not hide in yourself- hate yourself, not the one who merely transformed actions into words.
The best way to become an intelligent person is to agree with what I say.
What words you perceive as compliments or insults says much about yourself.
Compliment sparingly if you don’t want to have to constantly compliment out of etiquette.
The silence of an unfiltered cynical insulter is great praise for the wise.
Rhetoric is the art of speaking, and eristic the art of conversation.
What is the art of listening called?
Doesn’t matter since no one does it.
Indirect insults can shake a mammoth from slumber and smush a fly into the wall.
Gossipers give gifts of stories, with an emphasis on the blemishes of others. But they also give others the gifts of yours.
A good man’s words give grace to others, but he himself stays invisible.
I heard of a Rabbi who gives great advice for better matrimony.
“Have you tried shutting up more?”
Deaf people talk the most.
Smoking is a sign of stupidity in the sense that a smoker (at least in one point in time) allowed himself to begin a known addictive habit that kills you.
But smoking can be a cause of intelligence. It makes you talk less.
I hear silence well, so you shouldn’t feel like you need to add the critiques. Every absence of compliments is noted.
We can say more with less, and say less with more. It takes a true artist to say much with much and little with little.
R’ Wolbe- Humans need to be taught to speak, but once they know how they need to learn to shut up.
A fast mind speaks much, but even faster and the tongue is held.
Pan
Goats and Men
If it ain’t hell for the vulgar it ain’t paradise for the noble.
I would only be king if all my subjects were freemen.
The ancient philosophers emphasized constantly: all functions that humans share with the beasts are not to be complimented.
Diet-fanatics and foodies suffer the same disease of a sick, obsessed mind.
Anything that tries to make millions by becoming a staple must be offering something that even the wicked will buy.
Autonomy and comfort are a zero-sum game. If you allow slaves to do your work, you lose your independence. If you do it yourself you must exert effort.
The masses always chose comfort.
Cent-smart and dollar-dumb.
People will waste time looking for a free parking spot for the mall where they will buy the expensive luxuries that won’t give them any joy.
Based on my experience in the mall naked people induce consumption of ridiculous eyeglasses and pocket books. I guess if you’re not wearing anything you need somewhere to put your stuff.
“Shopping” as a pastime is more pathetic than whale watching at the Dead Sea as a pastime.
I don’t wish evil upon the masses. Who will bake me bread?
The zebra’s stripes serve as camouflage, by blending one zebra into the other. Humans, sometimes even colorfully clothed, act similarly.
There are only so many things you can know, and things you can know how to do. Choose wisely, and be certain to choose only some. Otherwise my life will rot like a flower before a TV screen.
To be void of tradition is to be brothers to apes.
People don’t care what direction you go, as long as you go far.
The best part of satire is the part where they make fun of something serious and then we laugh.
The best part of tragedy is when they make something serious and sad- serious and sad.
Trivialize the serious is satire, seriousize the trivial- that’s sports.
I don’t know how anyone can mock philosophical inquiries as being silly and still be an enthusiastic sports watcher.
When I see them I wonder: are they as bland as my imagination makes them?
If the choice is to be goat amongst goats or a lonely man- I choose lonely man.
Just smart enough to know that he’s evil.
The hope for a better tomorrow-man.
Few things reveal my consideration of man like small talk. We fear to put the stick in the puddle lest we discover how shallow it is. Come, let us talk of the weather and the food.
For every three sour lemons there is one sweet watermelon and fifteen dull, boring, goats.
For an opinion to be common to all is only proof that it is digestible to the masses, not that it is right.
The solitude of mind is a perquisite for any individuality of consequence- now being sold at your local mall.
The Stoics amputated the animal in them and freed their mind from passions they could not guarantee to fulfill. They made their kingdom small, only of themselves, and not a thing more.
The powerful mocks the weak and looks down at him as a man looks at a cat, or a Satan of Mark Twain looks at man. But if there is a conflict of powers that can pain one, a competition of importance, then one cannot be a laughing-stock, a thing of shame for the other. (Zarathustra).
The Stoics chopped off their arms and legs. Have they grown angel wings?
No goats long to transcend goathood.
Those that reflect are doomed to be lonely individuals in the masses of living corpses that surround them.
A vast majority of people cannot be inauthentic. Only one who is noble, can make himself common. Likewise, authenticity can only be demanded of the noble one.
Hold your breath until surfacing. Or be a fish.
The Caveman
Primal Nobility
One thousand men cannot pry open a jar of pickles together.
The people taken up by the rush to new and improved lifestyles of laziness cannot understand why one would choose to design their life in a different manner.
If you buy new clothes, and you do not lack any, you are wasteful. Perhaps your riches allow for waste; otherwise suspect advertising and the frailty of your mind.
To exit comfort as an end, is to break the clutches of the bovine on the soul.
It is not a lifestyle product but a consumer lifestyle that is the enemy. Every bland producer that creates a desire for more material consumption is a soldier of propaganda for the consumer lifestyle.
A consumer is one who defines himself by his possessions. And his possessions define him how the Ad-men say they do.
Constant stimulation of base instincts makes us baser, even if it is to teach us classical languages.
Can you go a week without a phone? Therefore: Invention is the mother of necessity.
Your phone experiences life more than you do.
A luxury is quickly a very fancy prison cell.
Anesthetics can hurt more than stitches.
Bureaucracy is a way for people who don’t like to take action or think to excuse themselves by placing responsibility on the ‘system’. What Kafka wrote as a horror is reality, with the exception that most of us have adapted to this life and know how to work it well. Those that don’t or won’t are screwed.
A bus driver has no autonomy in his job whatsoever.
Heuristic: If your job could be easily replaced by an algorithm, you have no autonomy.
But today, my bus driver rebelled, and let me go on for free. As far as he is concerned it’s his bus. And he is king of the caravan.
All men are born dependent. Autonomy is a process of blood and sweat.
A lion in a sheep’s wool cannot hide his roar.
The joy of autonomy is greater than the tyranny of joy.
Or: The rat that pushes the lever for a charge of electricity for happy time is pathetic, as opposed to martyrs who die in torture.
Do not let Mr. C play for you. (Kaczynski)
The self-chosen sacrifice becoming inaccessible, we choose to sing praises of the victim.
Every lion that attacks you is an opportunity for a majestic pelt.
To be proud of what others have done is the way of the weak. They cannot tolerate themselves as individuals, and so they must leech off of the false success. The strong are humble, but what is not theirs they do not touch.
Do not show your cud so the grass you ingested will be appreciated. Show your fleece.
(Based on Epictetus)
The wild charge of life is a mindset. The beautiful vigor of the beast is slumbering. Wake up!
I have pity on those who consider themselves pitiful. (Later discovered that Nietzsche felt similarly.)
Surrounded by fellows, I feel less like one.
I don’t understand the concept of ‘being offended’. It seems to be based on the presumption that other people’s opinions matter.
Pitying me is a sure way to be repaid with resentment and spite.
Appreciate me and my toil, and I will be grateful.
Joyous at the man’s mistake? Must be jealous.
Job
Life, Death and Suffering
G-d has lent me a lifetime, and with it the wonders of the world.
We are born naked, and we die naked. All that is in between is a bonus.
Is a child that dies a gift of life; albeit shorter than most others, or an untimely death? Is life a right that you deserve, or a gift from G-d? Easy to say, hard to know.
Would you deny a gift because it is only lent and not eternally yours?!
A miracle is a gift from G-d, but so is nature. Blind men do not see either. Open your eyes!
Upon further inquiry the miracle of life is no more miraculous than the miracle of existence.
Unconditional love is an unwanted gift to the noble, but they know that their very existence is such.
Life is a gift we have done nothing to deserve, but it comes with the curse that we instinctively demand it as if we did.
I heard a wretched child ask: “Why do good things happen to good people?”
The world fears suffering as if life could be good without it.
To accept suffering as punishment is to elevate the pain to redemptive repentance.
Near all of our pains are self-caused; and our ignorance to this is self-delusion.
Meditate on the blind man. Not in order to be happy you are not him, but rather to realize what you have.
At joyous moments we mourn those who are not with us to share them.
There is no light without darkness, no silence without music, no less without more. There are no virtues without faults and no faults without virtues. Perhaps most importantly, we cannot perceive life without knowing death.
The pessimist has the wrong base-line.
All that truly repent know that punishments are atonement.
Sleep is nature’s euthanasia. What difference does it make whether we lose time from the end of our lives or from the middle?
Civilization makes us complex so we can enjoy a symphony and suffer from jealousy of the composer. (Or the composer’s wife.)
Is it a worthy trade? Can it be reversed?
Mark Twain tried killing his conscience in literature, but I’ve yet to meet success in life. Naturally, if anyone was successful they would keep it secret.
What would we be without our complexity?
A good life has ups and downs. We all know how to love the happy, exciting times. Let us learn to appreciate the gloomy, misery as well.
Post-traumatic growth is the silver lining.
Sleep is my escape from pain. I would joyfully approach death if not for my eternal love of life.
Time wasting is mini-suicide.
Skulls often whisper in our ears before we attempt to decipher the words we must listen carefully to the coarse murmurs. That a skull whispers is enough of a surprise.
The worst part of another’s pain is that you cannot heal the faculty that controls the relationship to the pain. All your healing is a band-aid.
People think something is trivial because they have seen it is as common. But is death trivial?
The pain of the noble does not invoke my pity, but my love.
When I meditate on death I am not frightened as much as saddened.
Life can be a sixth finger.
Ingredients for a good life:
1: Don’t let death catch you in shame.
2: Know that death will surprise you.
Think constantly of death: it will make you a better man, and invigorate your day.
Your base line in life should be non-existence. Every moment is a gift.
Prepare for death constantly, so that one moment you can live.
With what frequency, intensity, and duration must one meditate death to live?
The fragile flower we hold will wither and rot. Imagine its demise one thousand times, not to prematurely suffer the pains of its death, but to appreciate its life.
I can think of the wretchedness of existence with ease, thanks to Voltaire and Samuel Clemens. Still, I see through the shadows the light that the Stoics and Maimonides taught me. The beauty of existence.
Have you ever wondered why we bury the dead?
Every night I visit death, and learn secrets of life.
Some live in luxury, all die poor.
Jacob
Truth and Lies
Do not blame the truth, that she sometimes reveals herself to the fools.
Do not blame art, that masses sometimes find her.
Do not blame G-d, that pagans and atheists are sometimes holier than his worshippers.
Without drive there is no entry to inquiry. With interest comes distortion. The only escape of the paradox is when the drive to inquiry is not for its own interest. How then are the truth-seekers to free themselves from these bonds?
Instead of charity raffles, priests should open up casinos and give the proceeds to charity. At least we would stay honest.
The world is so filled with lies that to say the absolute truth is the greatest lie of all, for men have already developed a function to turn lies into pragmatic truths. Alma DeShiqra.
You wouldn’t believe how much students cheat for their teaching degrees.
Do not be surprised if the source is self-entitlement, and therefore also a source of extreme aggression against students who laterally solve tests.
Most people knowledgeable on controversial topics (for example: the Israeli-Palestinian conflict), learnt everything after they already had a very strong and aggressive perspective. So their being informed on the topic does not make them a better judge at all. Of course they cherry-picked all the information they have.
In debate, one side will present the other as more extreme- and this strawman is obviously wrong. Even when recognized as a strawman argument we still fall for the trap as accepting the opposite argument as our baseline. Careful.
Salient blemishes hide other ones.
Don’t be tricked.
Those who adhere to dogma openly are more honest than the masses that pretend to be independent thinkers.
The most important secret is whether one has secrets or not.
The liars always make sure to mix truth in their stories.
Ego- the hero of truth and falsehood.
The truth is a cruel mistress. She forces herself upon you and worse yet, she makes you love and search for more of her.
To see a salesman in action is to see the devil incarnate.
Things that are not self-evidently important, that should be self-evident, are likely propaganda.
Timon became a misanthrope after betrayal.
Q: Did he think he was unique? For he was a generous man!
A: He knew the hidden heart of the flattered.
What a filthy reality where one must lie to be honest. Welcome to bureaucracy.
When the other side can’t understand the truth- telling them is as great a lie as silence.
A man praised for laziness is truly praised for doing much with little effort.
Tragically, honest statements in a world of liars are doomed to be misleading.
The wonder of hypocrisy is that it knows no limit.
To be honest is often to be alone.
But you may also be the address people turn to in times of their troubles.
To admit pride is not yet humility, as the sharp ones know that they receive the title of honest.
Most people would never admit that they deny things about themselves that are absolutely true.
And those that do would never admit it either.
Intellectual honesty is a virtue. So is honesty.
If I am trustworthy, it is only because I don’t promise much.
Of course I contradict myself- would you have me write everything at one time? Rather allow yourself to contradict yourself as well and see that at both times you say very good things.
Truth is bitter- but I like coffee.
Moses
The Biblical Narrative
The first impression of G-d is as the creator of the world as you know it.
The bible says G-d called the world ‘good’ (טוב) after creation. But today’s headlines would have to give it a bigger bang to get noticed.
Adam chose to sin with his love rather than stay perfect in the garden. Not good, not evil- human.
One thing life teaches us every day: we did not birth ourselves.
That shame clothes us is reason to be grateful for shame.
If we were to give animal sacrifices when we sinned as part of our repentance process before G-d, we would more easily believe that we are forgiven.
Alternatively, we may fall into the classic trap of attempting to bribe higher powers, leaving our souls stained.
A perfect human cannot be perfect in repentance.
Sometimes harsh cruelty serves to relieve future wickedness.
Joseph said: I will not sin to G-d! He did not mention Potiphar because one can always find in man an excuse to sin against him.
The Hebrews were not redeemed from Egypt to make them Egyptians. But they were still baited with a land of milk and honey.
Before joy, repentance.
One does not fear himself. The prophets met G-d, they did note unite with him.
Imagine a social critic today who was consistent with the Biblical Prophets. He would chastise us, saying “G-d does not want your prayers! He wants you to act in justice and kindness!” This is probably the opposite of what most preachers say. They say G-d wants you to identify with party politics.
The religious man is often a believer, sometimes agnostic and rarely an atheist. But never is he indifferent to G-d.
The prophets of the Bible are no easy read to an employer, or any other person of power.
He has heard the words of The Holy One through the mouths of the prophets and the voice in his heart. Our silly man ignores their cries yet still asks to speak to his creator.
Two men met a lion. One was struck with awe and wonder of the beauty, another with fear and trembling at the sight of such a powerful creature. The difference is between the men; there was only one lion.
I ponder if theEastern Dao and Israel G-d are the same. When a prophet met the indescribable he was struck to fear of the immensity and underneath that power he saw the pumping heart of love to the creation. He felt the furious demand for justice and the pride in humanity that acted in the ways of the L-rd. What the East feels- you must ask a man of that heritage.
In the book of Proverbs wisdom is represented as a good woman, a lover from youth. Folly is an adulterous slut. Today, people will hide sexuality in parables so as to avoid uncomfortable direct confrontation.
Interesting.
A prophet that does not disturb is not doing his job properly. Even the consolations of Isaiah have a sting.
It is offensive to say which sin brought which suffering- but it is religious to say that the good do not suffer.
At best- their suffering is for their own good, though they do not know it.
To overflow with virtue is true imitatio Dei.
Gideon
Doubt and Humility
The philosophers of the enlightenment had a platonified naïve interpretation of nature and reality. And they all loved it.
The counter-enlightenment had a chaotic, subjective interpretation of nature and reality. And they loved it.
It seems the mind often confuses the way it wishes things to be with the way things are, and I only assume the influence is in both directions. At the end of the day we are all front runners.
There is no Biblical prophecy of how the evil will rule the earth mixed with the demands to be just and good.
Rare, if even existent, are the believers of a divined justice of immense wrath- who still would condone evil.
When in doubt- shut up.
When sure of self- shut up.
When you know you are completely right without a shadow of a doubt- speak with humility, and offer your words as one of many possible positions, adding that you yourself aren’t sure about the truth of your proposition.
But when the house is burning down- Yell your lungs out.
I have a very difficult time defining a chair. But I sit on one without any definition at all, as do the multitude of those who have never bothered themselves with such trivial problems.
I don’t know how to define G-d. Can I still worship him?
A sensitive mind prefers to assume that it doesn’t understand.
I often confuse how I want the future to be, how I fear it will be, and what I predict it to be.
We prefer to see ourselves as heretics than fools. But perhaps the other really sees our faults, and is even more liberal (in the literal sense) than you in searching for truth.
The amount of waste one must go through to get to value makes one wonder if the time was wasted or spent.
When you have a conclusion everything is a proof.
Present proofs for your argument to someone who disagrees with your conclusion.
To know that you can’t know allows you to dance in joy for an extra minute before you die.
To know that you are just like the blind man on a dark night choosing which path to follow allows you to invest your energy in what is virtuous. For the blind man cannot know where he will end up anyway, and thinking about it is just a waste of time.
When faced with a sandstorm of information- stick you head in the ground and decide what you feel is right.
Good or bad advice?
What some of us know as obvious, others cannot conceive.
Who is naïve?
The ones who believe.
A lack of opinion on most issues is never wrong, and often right.
I plead ignorance- and then announce my thoughts.
Crafty.
The thought-tortured intellectual will often envy the fool’s quietude. This too, is a sacrifice on the altar of virtue.
Recognizing our weakness is humility when we know that we hold the potential for greatness.
When asked about the ideal teacher my wife thought of the terrible ones and inversed their attributes.
I thought of myself.
Humble was on my wife’s list of characteristics, but not on mine. Go figure.
You cannot ‘get better’ at being humble. Humility is simply to leave yourself. You can practice not being egoistic.
King Solomon
Search for Meaning
A good deed that you see as a punishment turns it into a crime. This is why most taxpayers are not saints.
Fame is measured by how many know of you. But truly, what do you know? The measure of life is what you have lived.
A reminder: Money made is not correlative with meaningful action.
If you don’t know what you’re doing, you might be doing something great. Or something horrendous. And likely- something trivial.
Doing meaningful activities creates a meaningful life and makes me a meaningful person. I often forget and think the causation is opposite.
Everything precious has an aspect of scarcity. All experiences are relative.
The problem with much of virtue and moral philosophy is the concept that it is a one-person mission.
To be remembered by G-d is reward enough.
The value of your good deed is in proportion to the value you give it.
Two isms are always at conflict unless they are identical. The hierarchy of values is a philosophical distinction, and what is a man with an ism if we disregard thought?
Most of life is speech. Does this bother anyone else?
Why? Should there be more action- or more thought?
It is a blessing to be comfortable in ignorance, yet discontent.
Life is a game of trivial pursuit.
The secret of much is that it doesn’t matter. But that ain’t the biggest secret.
Sharp enough to do well; yet blind enough to think that it matters. This is the summary of expertise in most fields.
Why do we care about logic when virtue is so far away?
It is like counting to see if the stars are odd or even instead of loving your child.
To any coded text there are infinite keys with infinite results. However, only one is correct. The game is almost as much about knowing the meaning of the key as the meaning of the text.
This is similar to the problem of finding meaningful information in an infinite text- the problem of the internet.
And more existentially, the problem of life.
Failure is a sign of aspirations.
When life does not reward you- play a game.
I have reached contentment prematurely- I need the pain.
Life is like that riddle about the raven and the writing desk.
I would forget much of what I know to remember the tortures a quest for truth brings.
“There is nothing new under the sun”- therefore meaningless.
“Everything withers to ashes”- therefore meaningless.
I wonder if Batman ever gets existentialist angst and wonders if it’s really worth the effort.
A man who thirsts for meaning, and is left parched in a cruel world, would only be all the more tortured with a life of a thousand years.
In the small details of my outlook on life I am relatively consistent. But the important question, of what is actually important- I find myself with a new aim every day.
Everything seems so bland sometimes. A thirsty man cannot imagine being quenched.
A night of tossing and turning in psychological agony is a sign of growth. But the next day’s action will reveal if it was an ascending growth of the cedar, or a cancerous growth of the spirit.
Upon seeing action, I long for action- to break the bondage of scholarship. But upon meditating action, I find it all folly.
When we search for meaning, we are really only searching for meaning for the faculties that do the searching. Hence, if meaning is an intellectual question expect knowledge and wisdom as the answer. If meaning is a religious question expect a religious answer.
When one despairs of the Messiah and the aptly named Utopia he is supposed to bring us to, the search for immediate meaning is intensified.
Does it not matter that nothing matters. That is, is the fact that everything is meaningless- meaningless? What the hell does that mean?
Protagoras
Language, Logic and Context
Everything ambiguous seems either meaningless or profound when meditated.
We use descriptions of public events to describe private ones. Eventually, the private event is communicated enough to be made a public term, but still diluted of the intensity of the original experience. The first man’s boiling anger was poetry- now common.
We birth a word. If it survives the community of speakers and their tongue breeds the sound and the letters of said word, it mutates with each generation. And after going through the sifts of time the word is finally an adult.
To create a word- to birth a concept. To popularize- to breed. The most potent of tools to mold man.
Definitions are a language tool to specify what it is we are talking about, and to avoid the confusion that words with multiple meanings have. But do not fall into the mistake that a defined word exists and a blurry one is meaningless.
To create a banner, a flag, a logo, a style, is to give the idiots a way to communicate their inner passions of power and idealism. In the end, the idiots’ symbol can only communicate what is in his mind, and so it is empty of value and filled with filth.
I only make myself the measure of all things because if I don’t, you will be the measure of all for me.
Step One: Symbols are taken as a mode of comprehending/communicating reality.
Step Two: Symbols are used far away from the reality they describe in time and place.
Step Three: The symbols are used without any reality imagined at all.
Step Four: The symbols are checked with reality, and they seem to hold. (Technologies such as mathematics)
Step Five: People deduce that all symbolic languages are primary to reality.
Step Six: Humpty-Dumpty pays the words to mean what he wants, and when they deny the salary, insulted at his petty cash, he gets pissed off.
Because every model constrains and takes effort to change; because every word is a caricature of reality; label minimally and with care, for labeling is no less than a lobotomy.
Labels function like fences, unnaturally dividing one reality from another and enclosing strangers together. So much power in words!
Having two words for the same thing creates nuances, and I will reckon more than nuances in reality creates words.
Cognitive load hinders our thoughts by slowing our mind in the mud of word search. Definitions are pockets to hold the load of many words, so that it may be easily lifted, like fruit in a basket.
A word is a mask with many wearers. But even the most distant of them are at the very least connected with the shared mask.
That we all have the vocabulary of politics gives us the sense of understanding and a right to an opinion.
Some words are like masks that change meaning in contexts and times.
Some concepts change masks in different contexts and times.
Perhaps one word with multiple meanings was one time experienced as one meaning with different contours.
Aggressive semantic analysis leads to confusion, but the only way to enter the palace of enlightenment is with a battering ram and a chocolate muffin.
A name/label gives the illusion of knowing more of something than we do.
A well that has no bottom is not deep, but it may be pleasant to swim in. Similarly, profound words that require effort to comprehend may be deep. But if there is no objective meaning, than there is no profoundness. What there may be, is a koan to meditate upon that may bring you some original insight.
To talk, to say, to speak. Many words, with many more meanings.
Exaggerations reveal superficiality. If a film is horrendous, what is a crime? If ice cream is bliss, then are you more than a goat?
A sick spirit (חולה נפש) in modern tongue means insane. But in medieval times it meant wicked and vulgar. When are the dark ages?
Ego depletion is a much better word than tired, because being too tired to go to bed sounds ridiculous, but being too ego-depleted to go to bed makes perfect sense.
Some words carry such a range of meanings that the abuse of them is easy and common.
Example: Addiction
Can you compare the state of a gambling addict who loans money from the mafia, to a man whose ears are more sensitive to the word ‘black jack’?
What is the meaning of the word ‘meaning’ in the question ‘What is the meaning of life?’
It would be valuable to know the difference between manipulation and influence.
It is not that good could not exist without bad, but that the recognition of a concept automatically includes its void.
Mental illness is an interesting metaphor.
A freedom fighter and a terrorist are one man from different angles.
An educator and propagandist, and employee and a slave, a student and a prisoner…
The problem with many philosophies is that they are too good with words, but not with life. So the descriptions, so poetically (as the essence of poetry is to affect the audience) delivered, mold our understanding of reality into the la-la land of the philosopher. Just read how the enlightened ones described the origin of society- fair and equal! And this brought us the revolutions of the 18th century.
Hunger today means desire- but in times of famine it meant writhing pain and the inner drive for survival.
What they call ‘science’ I call R&D of inhumane destruction.
What I call ‘scholarship’ they call a hobby.
What they call ‘entertainment’ I call drugs.
What I call ‘ethics’ they call cute.
What I call a ‘man’ they call a ‘dangerous rebel to progress.’
What they call a ‘man’ I call a good-looking, good-for-nothing bone bag.
What they call ‘literature’ I call a bunch of immoral toxic crap.
Reification is the blunder of politics and philosophy, but it is the success of mathematics and physics.
You cannot believe that ‘X’ exists if ‘X’ has no meaning for you.
Yet people declare they believe in ‘X’. This is to be explained that what they believe is something different than the philosophical analysis of ‘X’.
Examples: G-d, Souls, Justice, Love, etc.
I feel like sometimes- I only really think in nouns. Verbs are too slippery to grasp, and even when successful they often smell like a fish market.
Our mind, spirit, soul, psyche, heart, call it what you shall, is fragmented, but not like a mechanism that can be taken apart so each piece can be observed independently. Its better parable is an organism, and lungs are meaningless without understanding the heart.
In truth these parables are still lacking the fact that a thought has no parallel. Our faculties (senses, logic, imagination, etc.) are not ever alone. It is more like trying to distinguish between the circumference and the area of a circle. Each is needed for the other to exist in any way at all.
So how fragmented, you ask? In time! Each thought has a different path to tread than the other.
I cannot comprehend the mathematics, but the symbols and functions tell me the answer to questions like what is the product of five-hundred-thirty-six and forty-eight. And so we must ask, can a system of symbols, be a better description of reality than our own mental conceptions? In other words were the Kalaam correct in method?
Infinite regress as a ray: From G-d there are infinite causes until our reality.
The solution to the barber paradox is that there is no paradox if it is sequential. And if simultaneous, ‘the barber that does not cut his own hair cuts his own hair’
Interestingly enough, there exists no catalogue of all the catalogues that don’t contain themselves. I guess we’ll never know.
Tautologies are based on the concept that context is not a perquisite of meaning.
However, ‘all ravens are black’ is truly a sequential statement. It means: when you see a raven expect it to be black, and if it isn’t black then you haven’t found a raven (unless it is like a raven in every way except its blackness, in which case you have been disproved). However, ‘all non-black things are not ravens’ says that if something isn’t black don’t mistake it for a raven. To go through the logical necessities that can be extracted from each other is also sequential.
Another presentation: all the members of Set A are odd. This means that when I search in set A I expect to see odd numbers. But the logical conclusion that all non-odd numbers are not in set A, says nothing about the assumed meaning that one can find odd numbers in Set A. For finding even numbers in Set B does not say anything meaningful about Set A, and Set A might not even exist.
“What is happening when you see the red car?”
This Wittgenstein-ian question is based on a misuse of language. When we ask “What is happening when the red car is moving?” we are asking about the mechanism that creates the movement. We are asking for a description that will invoke a mental image of a process that we currently do not perceive.
But when we are seeing, we are seeing. That is- when we go through a mental process there is no description that would lead to a better understanding of said mental process than the experience itself.
It is a misuse of the question tool.
A parallel: you are given a hammer and asked to listen to a symphony with it. How hard you try, the music will not become nails.
I feel like philosophers stand between two mirrors and observe the myriad of reflections trying to find the real person. They seem to think that if something cannot be observed it is less “real” than the eye that sees. Curious people.
If I think a cat is behind me- and really it’s a tiger- am I wrong?
Would I be more wrong if it was a tiny puppy?
What if there was nothing?
Is there more wrong? Of course there is! But ‘wrong’ is one word with many meanings and shades- depending on reality!
The rules of logic are the rules of rigorous recursive thought- not the rules of reality, or even the rules of thought.
Inflation- therefore a penny saved is slightly less than a penny earned.
Logic- therefore a penny saved has nothing to do with a penny earned. A penny saved is a penny saved, no more.
If you know a number of objects, did you count them? Or is there another way of knowing.
If a statement has no meaning, the opposite of the statement has no meaning as well.
As ‘this statement is true’ is a closed circuit (therefore having no meaning, as meaningful language is in relation to reality), ‘this statement is false’ has no meaning.
Similarly, ‘This sentence is meaningless’ is meaningless’ just as ‘This sentence is meaningful’ is meaningless’.Although all of these are meaningless- ‘this statement is true’ through the context of the liar paradox points at the nature of meaning quicker than the others.
It is like ‘colorless green ideas sleep furiously.’ It proves a point, but only if your studying semantics.
Logic demands either true or false is because reality is exclusive like that. But language needs follow no such rules.
Can you have a one-time event that has a 30% chance of happening?
If the sentence is spoken by someone you’ll meet again, there is meaning to the numbers.
Commonsense is never rare, but its meaning changes with the common man.
I believe it is time Protagoras has had his revenge on Socrates. Socrates may be holy, but he does not understand how language works, while Protagoras does. The same word has many meanings, and context is needed for meaning.
The ability to realize that in other places and other times people perceived reality radically different than one’s self is a skill that any scholar needs.
Just don’t get carried away, for they wrote and left relics of their time in a different way than we do as well.
Which came first- a legal system or the criminal?
John and Jack seems like a specification of two people.
However, one can say John and Jack are in the room and be correct even if Bill and Ivan are in the room as well. One would be wrong if one said ‘two people’ are in the room. This is because ‘two’ means two and only two.
Again, language has meaning in context, and that context is reality.
Meta-analysis is an aggregation of multiple analyses. But hardcore Meta-Analysis is the ability to question the fundamental assumptions before going down to details. Not more information- more critical information.
The context of the speech is the speaker.
By speaking at length we give context to our words, hence injecting them with meaning. This is the method of Protagoras.
Liars and fools use long speeches to muddle. The Socratic antidote of two words per answer demands great care, for words have different meanings in different places. Without enough context words can be manipulated for the most exotic logical results.
The proof of no tautologies in language:
Compliment: John is smarter than Jack.
Insult: Jack is dumber than John
Gorgias
The Knack of Lying
It’s incredible that the dichotomy of apparent and real of Gorgias’s Socrates is even more relevant, and still not common knowledge.
From childhood to adulthood we grow in size. But in wisdom? That is the flattery that the commercial seller uses to defend himself in the court of G-d.
Riddle me this:
Everything rated is overrated.
Everything that should not be rated is underrated.
Lies, damn lies and statistics. If only Mark Twain knew what would happen in our time.
Apparentness versus reality- the problem of everything. A function of time?
The shorter the duration of information, the more apparent and less real it will be.
The less feedback, the more apparent and less real it will be.
Magicians can trick us for our entertainment- we give them dollars. But media-men trick us for our dollars- they give us entertainment.
The best manipulators make you believe that you don’t mind their manipulation.
Did the great men of past ever spend their time dreaming of great men of the past?
Perhaps another symptom of the partiality of media; it is not appropriate for the glory of Napoleon to show the hours he fantasized he was Alexander.
Consumerism is the ideology that the worthier things in life require purchasing.
If it can’t be sold- then it won’t be wanted.
The lie of television is that the characters don’t live as the audience does. If they did, then about a quarter of the time we would be watching people watching TV.
Similarly the quantity of pictures on social media are out of relation to the lives of the individual. How many pictures have you seen of people as they scanned through other peoples pictures on Facebook?
Customer service is not so well-named. Perhaps ‘company service’ or ‘customer manipulation.’
My only defense of advertisers is that they are just as ignorant as the public regarding the corruption they spawn.
If I didn’t know any better, I would think they were advertising the wonders of digital picture enhancement, not a food product.
Modern advertising has stabbed Love so many times in the gut that he is just holding on for dear life. No worries, soon to have a brain transplant anyway.
Advertising unhealthy food is the legal form of taking advantage of other humans’ mental weakness.
Running a casino is more honest than advertising for one.
With a catchy tune we will sing anything.
Socrates
Holy Rebel
The proud cannot be corrected, and therefore they cannot be wise.
Socrates taught that all are conceited. The conceited got pissed off. Big surprise.
Imitatio Dei requires one to abandon all importance of titles and names. I am that I am.
Search history for the witch hunters; then learn what you can from the witches.
Socrates did not teach anything new, but burnt down the illusions of the conceited.
Maimonides did not give a new description of G-d, but opened the veils to the room of truth.
Most people would rather be poor than ugly; stupid than poor; evil than stupid.
A hard-to-find righteous man would rather be dead than evil.
The saints would gladly sacrifice their intelligence, riches, and beauty for virtue.
It is not that the saintly philosophers are great and therefore allowed to ask the heretical questions. They are great because they ask.
Nietzsche was able to call philosophers naïve because from the mountain top he saw the diversity of contradictory opinions. The Academics and Skeptics, the same. But Socrates is the true hero, who had only the Athenians and the spoken word.
Creators of concepts disguise themselves as mouthpieces of the ancients.
I see this guy and I immediately like him. There must be some biases affecting me. It cannot be rational or based on anything true. Therefore- I hate this guy.
There are certain liberties that are granted only to those who will take them.
Example: If one requests the right to think for themselves- it shall not be granted.
Like fighting a brick wall with a plastic spoon; fighting the status-quo.
Non-conformists are often failed conformists. Sometimes they fail because conformity is too hard, and sometimes they fail because they are too great to be contained in a box.
A fact is no less wrong because it is offensive.
To be too arrogant to follow and wise enough to listen is a recipe for an intellectual rebel.
An honest man who preaches and teaches is willing to be cross-examined publicly by an equal.
The first commandment of G-d is a silent voice that whispers “Search for my will.”
Common knowledge is often forgotten. Being cultured is not synonymous or correlated with being good.
Throw out all those books that don’t make you a better man. Words that don’t grow into actions of virtue are poisonous illusions of greater worth.
If the word ‘sin’ is unspoken, and the lips silent with ‘holy’, all that is left is law and what’s ‘nice’. Who shall guide us? “Our bovine instincts!” they yelled.
To be rude is not a flaw when directed to superiors, but it is when directed towards inferiors (in power, not virtue).
Perhaps still- a sign of envy.
Changing reality is difficult because it demands force against material.
Changing people’s thoughts on reality is difficult because thought is flexible, and bends back to its original position naturally.
I live in a cage. To be free of my cage would be superhuman, but to be free inside is my duty.
First the art of life, and then the study of astronomy.
To be an iconoclast is to be holy if you leave the spirit alive. Otherwise you are left with goats.
To be virtuous is to mold yourself as such.
Laziness can make a man rebellious.
I’ve seen many goats in leather jackets. The one true rebel I ever admired wore a suit.
The great man is insane in the eyes of the commoner. But the commoner is base in the eyes of the great man. The heuristic is such- if a man is insane, he may be greater than you. If a man is base- more common.
To choose not to belong to any community/society often leaves you with those that don’t care about a virtuous life at all, instead of being companion to those that at least wear a mask of concern.
A house of worship without prayer books.
Most are less willing to interact with ideological antagonists than with immoral men of the same brand.
How does one rebel against a command not to listen to authority?
The paradox of Nietzsche and Sterner.
Epicurus
Material
Many believe G-d created the world as numbers and man created narrative, but the opposite seems more likely to me.
It seems to comfort us to blame the personality disorders of our loved ones on faulty chemicals, and not on faulty thoughts.
If you say that X has no meaning, you must explain why it has affected the world so much.
The sunk-cost fallacy is only a fallacy in the micro-world of experimental psychologists. A super rational being that didn’t function with the sunk-cost fallacy would be dynamic to the point of instability. They couldn’t keep a job, a friend, or a family for a month. Certainly, they would never be able to raise a child.
The underlying ideology of the treatment of the phenomenon is an immediate hedonistic approach to life, completely lacking the value of faithfulness.
Materialism has convinced the masses that only toxic substances exist and not toxic designs.
It is the naïve materialistic view that sees the essence of reality as objects, but the deep one that realizes that materialism is really a push in the opposite direction of thought. If only atoms exist then what makes reality as it is must be their relationship. Quality is a function of relationships and not of substance.
Put slightly differently:
Atomism really should lead to the understanding that the medium is more important than the content. What makes things what they are is their arrangement. The wave is real, the particles the metaphysics.
My thoughts are at my whim. When I stop thinking them they disappear.
Alternatively: I am at my thoughts’ whim. When they stop being, I disappear.
Causality is expected succession. The relationship is ‘A is followed by B’. Nothing more is needed. But ‘A’ is a singular occurrence. The riddle is making ‘A’ a general case. This requires the ability to compare similarities and differences. (What is a similarity?) And this requires recognizing which are critical and which not.
The good mind is a master of knowing and ignorance.
Rabbi Akiva
Sages and Teaching
Don’t take advice from a man who drinks cola.
One of my mentors told me today that he never rushes to anything anymore.
What inspires me is that this man is no-talk, all-do.
The most important secret is whether one has secrets or not.
You don’t deserve the questions you don’t ask.
Why do I always feel like people ask questions just to validate their own weak answers?
I am a teacher with nothing to teach but meta-skills. I’m either full of BS or really great.
Max Stirner: If one awakens in men the idea of freedom then the free men will incessantly go on to free themselves.
First: Popularizing the word freedom has changed its meaning. Today it means being a goat without effort, not being a noble independent.
Second: The true question that any educator is stumped with is- how do we awaken this idea?
It would be a great man who could spread sparks of darkness to blind our eyes to what is not worth our ever-depleting time. Even if he would blind us to some of the valuable sights, we would be closer to truth.
Teaching requires two skills; knowledge and how the other can learn it.
A philosopher asks first: What shall we teach?
An educational designer: someone who creates environments that are conducive to learning. These are lacking much more than teachers,
The symbiotic relationship between strong and weak demands that each retain his relative place. The truly noble make the weak strong and independent.
There are many advantages to be gained from idiots.
You can be happy in your lot- that you are not as foolish as they are.
You can learn how to be critical by picking apart pretty much everything they say.
What is the most important thing your father taught you?
Was it via lecture or jigsaw?
That differences exist between people in their qualities and abilities is irrefutable. There are those that would make all equal by falling the cedars, and those that would give wings to the earth bound.
The great teachers have students flock to them. If you must coerce your students to hear you, one wonders how worthy you are of teaching.
I can keep a secret. And there are secrets that keep me. And there are secrets that I scream, but nobody can hear them.
A life of contemplation cannot be the ultimate goal. That would demand contemplation to be action- but man is a social creature.
A life of contemplation is the perquisite for humble beings as myself to be able to do any action of value.
You can bring the donkey to the river but you cannot make him drink. If you try- you may drown him.
He provokes thought like a well aimed insult from your child.
The absurd is like a monster traveling on our intellectual territory. We can flee, freeze or fight.
To flee is to avoid the sight.
To freeze is to observe.
To fight is to incorporate the insanity into our psychology. A little bit is some spice on the meat. Too much, and you cough up a nasty vomit.
Patience is the key to education. Because the more you do, the less they grow.
Prince Judah
Jews, Judaism, and Devotion to G-d
The audacity of my religious fore-fathers to put Koheleth and Iyov in the corpus of the Bible is incredible.
If you think Moses was frightened when his staff turned into a snake, just imagine how much freakier it was for the staff.
It is interesting that those who so vehemently deny the right to religious law still stop at red lights, pay taxes, and sign the bank’s five-hundred page contract. Is it not possible that the laws of divine origin affect us correctly?
The illusion of being agents of control is easily destroyed by imposing some regiment of rules that are unnatural. Suddenly the natural and base urges can be sensed.
This is why religious people are more pessimistic/realistic about the limits of human self-control than seculars. The secular have never failed a black and white rule, because there are no black and white rules.
I believe in miracles, but I don’t believe you are worthy of one. Pardon my skepticism.
The writings of Epicurus, Spinoza, Paine and Russell cannot ruin religion as a smartphone can.
If you eat everything that’s available, how are you not a glutton?
Empirically, the great divide between religious and secular is not in belief but in action. That even the religious and secular do not realize this sometimes is very interesting.
Righteous of the Gentiles (חסידי אומות העולם) as defined by traditional Judaism, have nothing to do with saving Jews. You don’t even need to ever meet a Jew.
So, is it the traditional fanatics, or the Zionist Progressives that are ethno-centered?
One way to cure anti-Semitism is to exterminate all the Jews. We could also annihilate cancer by killing all humans.
A secular Jew is little more than a gefilte fish.
I don’t even live up to my heritage, and yet I wish to create more!
The Jewish Reform movement is not a failure; They have reached their objective of watered-down bourgeois modern culture under the title of religion.
Post-Mosaic authorship is less of a problem than complete indifference to anything in life but your new mating partner.
The Nazis were successful in making the Jewish identity a racial one.
It is interesting that there is compulsory education, compulsory laws, and no compulsory education of laws. Compare this with Judaism’s demand of education in the laws of the Torah as the foundation of religious life.
Kosher, Hallal and other religious diets can train us at the very least not to have all foods available all the time.
Spiritual and obedient to G-d are as synonymous as hedonist and altruistic are.
A magician can bring you closer to magic but not to G-d.
All things mechanical smell of the mundane.
To what limit should a covenant be broken, trampled and disgraced, before the covenant is null?
When we see a lofty ideal that we know we are still so distant from we must make sure to take a small action towards our destination. We cannot let ourselves forget, and we cannot let our children forget. Let the customs and rituals we forge strike a path to lead us to the better future.
We pay for a doctor to search for our most serious illnesses in order that we may be healthy.
How much will we pay for a critic to find our most terrible spiritual blemishes in order that we may be healthy?
It’s easier to condemn the heretics to hell, because we only must proclaim a faith.
But with sinners we have much more in common.
Man only sees the flesh of others, and turns his eyes from the only heart he can see. G-d, as it were, is neckless. The gaze on his thoughts is eternal.
That we lack connection to animal sacrifices of thanksgiving is not as much a sign of our compassion, for we eat meat, as it is a sign of ungratefulness. We are too callous as to feel the need to give thanks in action for the wonderful world we were given.
If your G-d does not influence and command the way you do business, eat and cohabit, then what good is your faith?
There is a very big difference between trusting G-d to take care of your problems and trusting G-d to help you succeed in your problem solving. The same is true of optimism. These two distinct facets of optimism are the difference between lazy naivety and daring courage.
There is a passion of lovers between man and G-d, and lovers when not loving are the bitterest of foes.
I find it difficult to pray without caring for another first.
The Sabbath- Literally a day of rest. A day of void. Via Negitiva as a nation’s holiest day.
Building the temple is the easy part. It’s finding the heavenly address to send the invitation to that’s difficult.
Marcus Aurelius
Strength and Courage
To make men of boys we should not teach them not to cry ever, but not to cry over trivialities. To make adults out of children- the same.
It takes a spine to save a Jew.
Even a legally blind eye can see that spines today are just as common as four-score ago.
And with slight insistence one can see that this problem has little to do with Anti-Semitism.
Responsibility- not disappointing others.
Integrity- not disappointing myself.
Most brave men are normal, but uniformed about the odds.
To be brave, do not burden yourself with changing yourself, warp reality.
Actions speak louder than words, and some words even whispered are actions.
The brave search for adversaries. The cowards cherry pick examples to prove their point.
For the noble- the action is enough. Success is a bonus.
Be strong enough to be indifferent to another man’s folly.
Fear errors more than their discovery by others.
No blood was spilled to bring the water to King David, but the risk that his warriors took was great enough to make it unworthy of mortals.
Shame saves us from shameful acts. But shame that is too weak to influence behavior is cause to be ashamed.
Much envy in criticism. But the purity of the source of criticism is not identical with the truth and value of the critique.
Hope and fear are friends that do not part.
A fool’s bravery is ignorance of danger. True courage stares fear in the eye.
A useful word: To fantasize- to want something, but not enough to do anything about it. I need to get out of bed.
King Solomon: “Spare the rod, hate thy son.”
And to spare oneself of the rod?
Socrates taught us: an itch is an itch, regardless of its physical location.
To speak of reward and punishment for virtue is to degrade the holy to sludge, like paying cash for love.
We were given two eyes, so we would learn to blind one of them to the garbage that we swim in.
The only thing to fear is fear itself.
And once fear arrives you’re doomed in a vicious cycle of horror.
Maximus Spartacus
Slaves, Employees and Other Victims
The cruel bosses never talk to employees or customers. Rather they employ middle-men bureaucrats that only repeat: ‘It’s not up to me.’
There is perhaps no greater example of the evil bureaucracy can allow than the atrocities of the governments of modern times.
Do they really care about the ill? Or is it simply that depression and other maladies are inefficient?
Motivating someone to do something they don’t want to is called manipulation.
Read up on the literature about how teachers motivate students.
To label is to excuse. It makes your questioning unacceptable because the title proves that what is being done is socially legitimate.
‘I am a soldier’ – So therefore my obeying is to be unquestioned.
‘I am an employee’- So therefore my obeying is to be unquestioned.
‘I am a scientist’- So therefore my act of research is to be unquestioned.
‘I am an advertiser’- So therefore this list is making me depressed.
Alexander only saw subjects when he saw men. I only see men when I see sheep. But my faith is fading.
I cannot help but blame the innocent for blaming themselves instead of their manipulators.
Irrelevant of the reason, if you feel you cannot quit you are a slave. Let us be slaves to virtue and not to gold.
My 90 average tells me that I have average intelligence plus the most important attribute in modern society- brainless obedience. I have a scholarship that demands it, but I am still disgusted. The scholarship itself is a sign of my submissiveness.
The best qualities of an employee are: submissiveness, high motivation to please superiors, lack of self-esteem (so as not to usurp them), and squareness (because an imagination and the guts to act on ideas is very dangerous.)
To be a student is to be a slave. Your compulsory toil is to get yourself a grade
Division of labor makes wretched producers and multitudes of products.
Would you trade comfort for meaning?
A heuristic for knowing how submissive you are: How much paperwork do you do?
If you think this is not a good heuristic because you enjoy paperwork then you have already been broken.
When office jobs are the standard, how can intellectual courage be a virtue?
Only weaklings work when they have enough money. Pity the weak!
Even schools divide labor.
I used to not be able to multitask, but now in school I have learnt how to listen to the teacher and do nothing simultaneously.
Doing anything you don’t want to, for people you don’t like is a condition reminiscent of slavery.
I hate it.
I wish people were less like cockroaches and more like wolves. That is to say, I wish people were stepped on by others less and had larger canine teeth. I think canine teeth look cool.
Blessed is the slave who knows his place.
Honor your superiors, respect your equals, and pity the rest.
Poverty is often a state of mind.
Rather the empty stomach of the wolf than the stick and collar of the dog.
Nothing is more offensive than being pitied.
Self-imposed poverty is the most flattering attribute of the society I live in.
A life of leisure is a necessity for a life of critique. But a life of an academic is hardly a life of leisure. The life of unemployment and simple living with a decent inheritance is the life of leisure that allows freedom of thought.
Just get your hands dirty once in a while so you don’t disconnect your imagination from reality.
I feel I can’t be bothered to care about what everybody else is thinking about everything. Too much effort.
Laziness as a source of freedom.
.
Rabbi Yehudah HaLevi
Beauty and Genius
Coffee, cigarettes and art are all acquired tastes. But one loses its effectiveness with time, one kills you, and one makes you feel alienated.
Rigorous thought is not to be equated with science. Many are the deep, critical, intellectuals who have nothing to do with discovering the underlying rules of nature.
The majestic words with humble meanings bring us to the proper perception of reality. An enchanted child and autistic person see the same thing, but have different states of consciousness. Words and their abuse can bring us to see the world we know differently, perhaps even truthfully.
Art is a portal to a deeper relationship to reality, entertainment is a distraction from it.
Magnificent novelty is ex nihilo. All else is progress.
Even when the wolf devours the sheep there is harmony. Just try not to get too far into the sheep’s head.
The first follower of a rebel is more authentic, novel, and noble than assumed.
Super crazy people often make me question how strong my grasp on reality is. These people don’t sound so different than myself, just they don’t have a society yea-saying with ‘em.
It’s easier to see the child that speaks than the philosopher that wrote.
Sometimes the credit goes not to the great leader but to the shadow that anointed him.
There are men who seem to be fools to those that don’t understand them, but those that understand them know they are genius. There are men who seem genius to those that don’t understand them, but those that do know they are fools. The latter group outnumbers the first a hundred to one.
The best definition of genius I have heard: A novel idea, once known, does not allow thinking the contrary. ~ I. Breuer
The attempt to quantify even the most spiritual is a mistake that automatons make. It is a mistake that makes man into an automaton. It turns a sunset into a chemical compound. But the artist can make even a chemical compound into a sunset.
The greatest tactician ever was the first to prepare for battle.
Hollywood: where every experience is exploited for cash.
Things that don’t make sense can be interpreted as a sign that we are rational beings that can only digest symbols close to truth.
Or
Maybe you’re just not smart enough.
I philosophize and polemicize as an artist does. The truth and its social application is a most potent for beauty.
Indeed, we philosophers so insightful concerning our own naivety are still so naïve concerning our own insights.
To be an artist that lives the process as its own end is to live a full life.
The blackest night makes for brighter stars. And an exploding sun makes for the end of earth.
Solitude.
Maimonides
Via Negativa and Divine Awakening
The mood of a man affects his perception so much. Meditate how much being human would warp and distort what we see from what truly is.
In a world of inanimate objects- we learn how to intervene and interfere for results. Activity is rewarded and patience becomes rarer as a usable skill in many fields. The illusion of worthlessness for a grand virtue makes it all the more valuable.
Prioritizing is accomplished via negativa.
Subtractive solutions are most beautiful elegant creatures of destruction. To plow a field before planting.
Enlightenment, Zen, whatever it’s called; the psychological frame of mind that places one in a perspective so radically different from all that surround a man; the ontological status of being-above and beyond the common reality; all this seems to be disconnected from the actual ideology that brings man to such a place. I plead ignorance, but my intuition says that these are many paths to the same destination.
To be a skeptic in the face of absolutes is easy.
Nothing as void is very different than nothing as trivial.
When seeking a savior we ignore the search. When we find ourselves seeking as an end, we kill the seeker. How can we live as a seeker who has found himself?
Growth. Everything is a matter of language.
When Abraham smashed idols, he had yet discovered G-d. Rather no map than a wrong one.
To accept truth is easier than to expel falsehood from our mind.
Maimonides taught us: the more you know, the more you can negate of G-d. The first half of knowledge is raising to awareness that which we think; the second half, denying it.
Controlled ignorance is the key to wisdom, as controlled folly is to awakening.
A mass man is inconsistent in his folly, because he is not an agent but a tool of the environment.
The opinionated man is consistent in his folly, because he is an agent, and a tool of himself.
To leave folly is to leave the category of consistency and inconsistency.
No one knows anything.
The arrogant declare “You don’t know anything!”
The humble whisper “I don’t know anything.”
When you feel yourself a fool you are wise.
When you feel yourself wise you are a fool.
This is the secret of Socrates.
The end of knowledge is to know we don’t know.
The test of religion or philosophy is less in the explanations, more in the idols it smashes.
It requires no effort of the fools to be a fool. But of the brilliant it is a trial of immense proportions. This chosen ignorance is common to many of the mystical traditions.
Can you read The Guide for the Perplexed without hearing Buddha?
Leo: Master, I long for G-d. Please help me find him!
Abraham: What is G-d?
Leo: If only I knew- then I would be with him!
Abraham: How do you know you wish to cleave to G-d if you do not know him?
And so Leo was awakened.
The ways to G-d are like the stars, can they be counted?
The ways that do not lead to him are the dark spaces in between.
It is painful to be gagged by reality, and not be able to share deep knowledge. But the sign of a true secret is that it has value, even without the ability to share it.
To kill a great religion- define it. Confine it into a box the size of your brain.
Shame is aroused when my self image meets reality, and I am found wanting. Perhaps I should be joyous in discovering another truth.
G-d is frightening and awe inspiring, so that we are petrified in his presence. For our grandparents- there was nowhere to run away to. For goats of today- there is the other hill.
Being faithful to G-d is very meaningful. Having faith in G-d keeping promises that he never made- a crutch.
In medieval philosophy it was taken for granted that there was an objective perfection called ‘G-d’ and because of G-d’s ontological perfection he must be static- as any change could only be a blemish in relation to the perfection.
I feel it is time to recognize that what we call perfection is yet another anthropomorphism that must be overcome. There is no perfection in a vacuum. G-d can change and react to the world.
The philosophical G-d is sometimes more naïve than the fundamentalist G-d, trying to chain the light down with weights.
Fear- paralyzing, overwhelming fear is the appropriate response to an encounter with G-d.
To pray is to know your place in creation.
It is only right to flee in awe from the Creator. But where should one run to if not to his source?
It is the paralysis that the holy strikes in us that allows an authentic love. If there is no respect that tosses our stomach in fear and reverence, our love of the holy is trivialized.
Deep truths are like flashes of lights, quick to disappear. If we are given a gift from above, we may have many consecutive flashes, so that the light seems constant. But to the man who experiences enlightenment, it is always flash after flash.
I wish to be closer to you, though I know that close to you would kill me.
Gutenberg
The Written Word
The Naïve believe all numbers have meaning of value, and all printed words authority not to be questioned. The Skeptic inquires what the context is, who speaks, why they speak, and much more, and still suspends judgment.
I can read many books at once, and feel no need to finish the first before starting the second. I would not limit myself to only conversing with one person until all we had to say was exhausted before I began another conversation.
Skimming pages in a book is like ignoring someone as they speak to you, minus the risk of offense. But the risk still stays that you might miss something worth knowing.
If you understood everything in the book the first time around, you’re going too easy on yourself.
If one has too many technical words in the book- suspect fraud.
The silence of the text screams louder than the print to the sensitive mind.
I can read wisdom and be upset that I didn’t think of it myself.
So much for the altruistic facet of knowledge.
The fact that something is written gives it authority.
If you’ve never reread a book, you’ve never read a good one.
If you’ve never reread a book, you’ve never read properly.
Read not to know, but to live.
The fuel for my thought are the books I read. But not necessarily the books I agree with.
Slow thinkers and quick ones are equalized in writing and reading.
You can’t study history without the written word, and you cannot understand historical writings without studying the history of words.
The written media encourages static thinking. No wonder all the philosophers lack the dynamics of reality.
Any book can be esoteric if you’re dumb enough.
The placement of the title has a massive effect on the poem.
The first lesson from children’s literature: animals commonly talk.
Second lesson of children’s literature: often animals are named as their species.
If I want a cruel story that teaches me nothing I’ll read Hans Anderson’s Fairy Tales. No need for the news.
In order not to be fashionable, converse with others culturally distant in place or in time.
In a good book the author thought more than the reader about what is written.
In a bad book- nobody thinks.
The many words that have been written are worth nothing if they don’t provoke a reaction.
So why do I read so much? Because there is much dirt over the gold.
The printing press did not give manuscripts to the masses. The new medium changed the nature of text.
Erudition is a blessing if one thinks more than one reads.
You love an author when you wish they had written more books.
The best books have forced me to put them down in order to be a better man.
The standardized writing of academia is obviously silly to anyone not in academia.
When reading a book, I saw a youth looking at me quizzically. ‘You teenagers just don’t get it’, I muttered to myself. They can’t help the fact that they’re not cool.
I, like, kind of pity them. Whatever.
It’s not that grammar is needless. It’s just that demanding that all writing meets the criteria of grammar is foolish. Good grammar is a tool for enabling comprehension. Let us rather demand that all writing meets the criteria of intelligibility.
There will not be an apology for the art form of a novel printed in the introduction, but a book of aphorisms is likely to contain one. The exception demands a defense. But I say that the popular is completely uncorrelated with the good. Perhaps even more so, a novel demands an explanation of how such a common form of media fit your ideas so perfectly.
To defend an argument poorly is to weaken it. Hush!
If we think in words then writing without premeditation is thinking.
To write your insights is to open your present to the critique of the future.
Is writing doing? Is there any action in my writing, or is this just like no-substance-speech? Am I missing life, or living?
Who does one write for?
If one writes for dollars and cents, then the audience should be as broad as possible, including the stupids, the sillies, and the illiterate if possible.
My writing portrays me as much more pretentious than how I see myself.
But in truth am I pretentious?
G-d will judge.
I don’t imagine anyone will like everything I write. I don’t want anybody to. I write for the one who enjoys reading another thinking person’s thoughts, even when that person is wrong.
I want my book to be the most annoying, challenging, thought-provoking, enlightening it can be.
I can congratulate myself on my writing if my texts, upon being read, cause the reader to shut the book and grow from themselves. Words that act as beasts, chasing my audience into reality. Letters like seeds that can be planted in the minds of the reader, but that demand the toil of light and water to live.
I am a failure if I am a form of entertainment, in which the reader passively drinks in my oozing letters.
It does not take much imagination to interpret aphoristic texts into a systematic paradigm of your wish.
Emerson said “I hate quotations- tell me what you know.”
Niccolo Machiavelli
Politics and Hierarchies
Sanhedrin (8:5)- Wine and sleep of the wicked are good for them and good for the world.
I suppose social media as well.
To be a sports spectator is to be boring and dumb. To be a sports hero is to have status in the eyes of the boring and dumb.
I would not mind being a gnat for a giant to step on.
It is easier to have an opinion, and even easier to have a strong opinion the more ignorant we are.
Imagine a cockroach proud of the Great Wall of China, “I am a Chinese cockroach!”
Now imagine a Chinaman born centuries later who claims the same.
Now imagine a Jew proud of the prophets.
Over-socialization is the failure to see that what people say is different than what they do and think.
Remember this when criticizing/criticized: To hold to one to higher standards is to respect them. Alternatively, it may be a sign of cheap hypocrisy.
It bothers me when a person in power behaves in an ‘innocent’ manner that cannot be reversed.
A teacher calls a student by a nickname- the student cannot retaliate because the teacher controls the grades.
Liar! You oppose prostitution not for any noble reason, but because this week it isn’t in fashion!
Sanity is to be normal in the eyes of people who have so many flaws that conformism is an insult.
Those who will not teach their children to physically defend themselves should protest against the enforcers of law. Does the written word make actions just?
A doctorate from Latvia in Chinese medicine is a way of signaling that one is smarter than really stupid people.
Most authorities should be recognized as powers of might, not powers of right.
To blame the system is not to shake off responsibility if you are willing to fight it. Contrariwise, if you blame the cell instead of the organism you are distorting the truth.
When all the elite are fools, you have yet to find the domain of the wise.
Be careful not to call victories and failures of others your own.
When single parent families are commonplace, expect the next generation to be warped. It has nothing to do with socio-economic factors. It has to do with a generation that did not grow up with a heritage.
Hereditary positions of power may weaken the institutions they head, and even corrupt the powers they hold. Nonetheless, they create an environment where family loyalty trumps practical utility.
In the biblical narrative, Samuel’s sons were removed from power, not because hereditary inheritance is looked down upon, but rather because of their moral failures.
Some moral failures are so strong that the value of family cannot stand up to them, but no utility is more valuable than the institution of the family.
Patriotism only means that you value and cherish your heritage. But what is your heritage? Do you know more of your wars than of your saints?
The ideology of the primacy of the family unit over a mass society needs a symbol for the dissidents of modernity to unite. But it is very hard to unite under a banner of via negativa.
Tribal laws respect other groups much more than universal laws, even if they command the tribe to fight others. We would make you corpses, but we would not make you into us.
Upon reading a story from Henry George:
The bandits who become capitalists- is this a sign that property is theft, or that property is a blessing that stops throats from being slit.
There is no escaping facts; lives can be converted into tax deductions and candy-bars.
It is incredible that the lowest cultures of the western world are adopted by others. We should inquire if this is what makes the receivers of said culture vulgar, or their vulgarity found its match.
When being a lawyer is not considered a noble occupation the system of justice is not fulfilling its function properly.
Do not take pride in a collective’s achievements just because you share their name.
What is the difference between the vulgarities of contemporary politics and the politics of Athens, Rome, Jerusalem and other kingdoms of old? Perhaps the Lindy Effect is a proof of their value. Perhaps the fact that philosophers utilize their history in their writing demands their knowledge. Perhaps there is none. (DesCartes) Perhaps knowing the past helps you understand your present. (Maimonides)
Perhaps.
Those Yankees who can’t sympathize with the Confederacy should examine how they would react to losing their sweatshops. Would they own two pairs of pants and one shirt with a smile? (Forget the sneakers.)
Employee = Slave, and Policy Maker = Slave master.
The teachers do not control education. The controllers of the curriculum do. The controllers of the school design do.
There are always elites and masses. But the main question is with what criteria do you divide them?
The elite gladiators and cage fighters versus the masses of men and women who have never punched someone in the face?
The elite musicians and musicologists versus the masses of pop-lovers?
What is the divide?
The underlying biases of the academic world is that academics are important- not knowledge, not wisdom, not thought. Not practical ability and not theoretical critical thought.
Those destroyers of history do not know that they are the bastard child of who they wish to kill.
A hyper-democracy encourages the election of manipulators.
It’s a good thing the Nazis weren’t liberal democrats- for then we would have to be fascists.
Maimonides:
To design a system that gives men peaceful lives is good.
To design a system that makes men good is divine.
Can a Marcus Aurelius be elected in the era of mass media?
I doubt if a Seneca would succeed.
I believe we had anarchy at one point, and it led us to this cursed civilization. This realization killed the anarchist in me, but his ghost haunts me still.
It seems like the world is in one big prisoners’ dilemma and constantly choosing to betray.
Only for the filth of the world do we play the stag hunt.
In real politick we would just put a bullet between the Cheshire cat’s eyes. Beheading is so formal.
A soldier must be brave enough to risk his life in combat and submissive enough to take orders from any superior on blind faith. As Plato says, the best soldier is likable to the best of dogs.
To be liberal is to want to break traditional values. To be conservative is to want to keep the world with its faults. Say it as it is, and realize that there is always a sacrifice.
Men are created unequal. To make men equal is the fruit of millions of rivers of blood and sweat. Only equal is a pocket with two meanings, as there is inequality in power, and there is diversity in personalities. It seems we are striving very hard to destroy diversity with the hope that inequality will fall after. It is true, after all, that there is no king of goats. But would we buy equality at the price of dignity?
Laws are by nature coercive in the sense that they would be redundant if their content would be practiced without them, and obsolete if they did not come from the mouth of an authority. Law is instrumental for the great educators to plant the seeds of virtue in society.
Sadly, today, law is considered only a means to making the rival party angry and control people from hitting each other.
I’ve found many debates on the question of capitalistic vs. socialistic economic systems to be based on the assumption that the poor of today should be more like the rich of today, tomorrow.
Sadly, envy of the rich is not in their leisure to do anything worthwhile, but simply to have more.
When the government was hardly more armed than the citizens, ideas were truly dangerous. A mob could mean a revolution.
Sadly, one must admit that in the contemporary state of technology, ideas are somewhat barren and rallying cries, obsolete.
Real Politic teaches us that there is a sacrifice that is needed for virtue. But hide this from the masses.
Quiet wolves eat screaming goats, and the shepherd with the headache silently gives gratitude.
Cultural capital makes culture mean whatever the rich guy says.
In a democracy, people who have an agenda (righteously or otherwise) need the most votes. Everybody is to be convinced that the situation at hand is important and of a certain stance towards it.
It is completely irrelevant if the voters are knowledgably informed on the topic, or if their stance stems from any logical reasoning.
You can vote pro or anti segregation without knowing how to distinguish between (a) theories of races and (b) a triathlon.
Neil Postman requested ‘knowledge polls’ instead of ‘opinion polls’. Does he really want our ignorance, and worse, our extreme irresponsibility in convictions revealed?
Well… do we?
I recently heard that the ends of the political spectrum have much more in common than adherents believe. Interestingly enough, much of my greatest critique falls on the common territory of the fools.
At the end of the day, dead soldiers are a sunk cost.
Michel de Montaigne
Reflections
You can hardly perceive what qualities you lack, but what qualities you have you must infect the world with. Therefore, to measure your qualities, reflect on what you most easily see.
Do thoughts create the mind, or the mind the thoughts? Either way there is no brain.
If being hungry makes you rude, then eating is an act of charity.
Acquiring a bad habit is like growing a sixth finger. To amputate it is messy and painful. To leave it is to stay blemished.
Envy is a diagnosis of your blemishes.
Nothing nauseates me more than the repulsive facets of myself.
My inner rooster is a lazy bum.
William James Psychology pg 8 “A cup of strong coffee at the proper moment will entirely overturn for the time a man’s views of life.”
That man would be me. The proper moment is every morning.
To accept who you are means to accept the part that protests.
There is a transcendental plane of existence for man to walk on.
I’m not a hypocrite! I hate that about myself as well!
Reflection is the exit from vulgarity.
Uncompromisingly honest reflection is the scimitar of the noble philosopher to hack through the wilderness of illusion.
When a man trivializes or protests always suspect sour grapes.
Note: some grapes one cannot reach truly are sour.
Regression to the mean:
Sadness is caused by happiness.
Do all slightly above average people like myself find themselves geniuses? My gut hurts from the thought that I may just be vainly full of pride.
The resentment I feel towards the powerful is my true weakness.
Arrogance is an antidote to envy that requires a cure itself.
The best way to get something done is to have something different you loathe to do waiting for you.
When I transcend myself by accepting and surveying all the wars and contradictions inside me, I expand myself. My soul digs its roots deeper into the nourishing G-dliness that feeds it.
If writing is not good for my pride, does that mean that my writing is good?
If people knew even an eighth of an eighth of my faults they would be ashamed to even look in the face of such a sinner; but if they knew an eighth of an eighth of their own faults they would be just as ashamed to look in the mirror.
“I couldn’t care less what they think about me!” Translation: I care what they think about me, but I’m pissed off.
If you don’t know what you’re doing wrong in life then I can tell you that at the very least your self-awareness needs improvement.
What a man praises in others is often a deeper revelation of his soul than what he is praised for.
What a man is praised for is a deep revelation for himself, if only he would hear what was being said, and not just how great he is.
Just as we need darkness to see the stars and silence to hear the sunrise, we need solitude to see and hear ourselves.
Just smart enough not to know that he’s stupid.
The tragedy of mediocrity.
There is always a sacrifice. You cannot be perfect in every way. The saint, the poet, the warrior, the philosopher, the scholar and the king cannot reside in one body.
How does one choose?
Every man has a mode of perception with which he distorts all reality as it enters his mind. A musician hears the music differently than others.
Is there a tool to mold our soul to perceive reality differently?
The parables and metaphors we think with are one of the major factors of how we perceive and live.
Control the F.I.D. (frequency, intensity, duration) of these parables.
We perceive ourselves as cooler, more reflective than we really are because when we reflect about ourselves we are activating these facets of our personality. When satisfied we cannot imagine hunger. As an antidote we should observe others, and have the average be the base line.
We accept all our basic principles for interpreting life from others on account of authority and popularity. It seems justified as a baseline but not as a conclusion.
My pride is hurt most when my de facto superiors are my intellectual or moral inferiors.
I take great compliment in what my detractors don’t say about me.
Like ‘gullible’ for example.
The stupidity of people intrigues me, but my intelligent friends find it not worth any thought.
Is it the reflection or the strangeness that causes such a reaction?
I wouldn’t trade me for a million of you.
I hope you feel the same.
Empathy- entering another’s emotional world.
Vulnerability- opening the doors to mine.
I wish the causes of my frustration could be solved with procrastination. It seems the causes of my frustrations are procrastination.
It is so peculiar to see how a person who has only met one specific facet of yourself generalizes and creates a personality so distinct and foreign to the truth.
I wonder how often I do the same to others?
How often do we notice in others faults that are our own?
How often do we notice that the same faults are our own?
As a social animal, I know my identity in relation to the larger society around me.
I am a liberator. I can help you free yourself from the bondage of dependence. I can clean you from the media toxic. I can nourish your soul and train your mind.
But really, all I can do is turn your neck to look at life from a different angle. Now you have to use your perception to see, and sight to perceive.
Essentially, I am either a philosopher of the highest caliber, or a quack.
If I’m a quack, I’m fooling myself as well.
To be witty is to think of a comeback before the insult comes. But never ever admit it.
It’s easy to be witty if you have some salient deficiencies. You know what to expect.
A dynamic personality is how a hypocrite self-describes themselves.
No matter how useless we strive to be, the plastic bag in the ocean wins.
A person that is never wrong is always wrong.
CBT is a two step process. The first and more important part is to create a habit of introspection at critical times. Usually people don’t think at all. They just do. The best thought (or perhaps more exact- semantic thought) is one that flows completely with the reality we are currently present in. So this thought is the “old” or “bad” thought we want to change. But truly, we have first created this thought in order to habituate thinking semantically with the trigger. Next, we kill the old thought by replacing it with a new one. It is much easier to exchange semantics than feelings and their flow of effects is two-way.
Why does a peacock have wings?
The despaired answered: Why do I have a mind?
The artist answered: Why do I draw?
The believer answered: I don’t know, but I love.
The wicked answered: Why do I have a knife?
The proud answered: To fly.
The pilot answered: He has no wings!
The scientist answered: His parents had wings.
The child answered: … (The child didn’t know how to ask.)
Lose a piece of your mind and you may gain peace of mind.
One man’s garbage is another man’s litter.
I would like to explore the different kind of self-destructions we humans engage in. It would be a useful book, would it not?
Sometimes we are with an evil heart, sometimes with a clever mind, sometimes with a pure soul- and always with all.
Never demand anything of others and protect yourself from the label of hypocrite.
Sometimes, I wish I could exchange lives with him. I would trade personality, history, body and mind. And then I see that we have switched, and now I that was him is stuck with pitiful me.
J.G. Hamann
Killing the Squares
A dichotomy of dichotomies. Those that relate to a dichotomic reality, and those that do not.
Which is bigger, ya think?
Static thinking as a result of a sluggish life. But not slow enough to realize that life is not static.
Maybe the world can be successfully Platonified and quantified. But I would prefer the error of autonomy.
You cannot drink a cup of milk and then swallow a spoonful of cocoa.
Definitions are a precise manner of communication, but concepts themselves are often vaguer than language pretends. Stories are often a better alternative than definitions.
The platonification of reality is such a disease that you need an awakening to be released from his spell.
That we can translate everything into numbers probably means that we understand numbers less than we think we do. They have become magical measurements.
“She’s a ten!” probably is a sign of diminished understanding of numbers, rather than an augmented and deep perception of beauty.
The worst victims of education believe that human value can be translated into an objective number, and that number is to be decided by an external agent.
These victims are equally students and teachers.
Some differences between life and the prisoner’s dilemma:
That in life you can bribe the prison guard or get a lawyer. (Change the game)
The outcomes cannot be quantified. (The values of outcomes are unknown)
There is such thing as virtue. (There is no game)
To emphasize metrics is to blur the lines of quality. Numbers can make one a fool.
Most secrets are like most pieces of information. Worthless.
Magic degrades the sacred into the mundane. Would you have a clockwork G-d?
When you live in the forest you can only see the trees.
If you study your ideology, you are not living it as action, but looking with distant scholarly eyes.
Ignorance is a perquisite of life.
It is easy to survey the world from the top of the mountain, but the trick is to remember the map when you are down.
When surveying from the mountaintop, remember what knowledge is actually important for people down below.
It’s hard to find a reason to get upset with a rational model. Because nothing matters in a descriptive perception of reality. Is this beyond or below good and evil?
The school system is the most powerful invasive “Bed of Sodom” that I can imagine. Everyone learns the same thing?! Based only on age?!
The best people are still severely blemished. What a great imagination we must have to even conceive of the perfect man with which to compare all others, when that man has never been met.
I think everything is in essence a duck, but appearances are deceiving. Still, you cannot prove me wrong.
Village Idiot
Everything is Wrong
A fools criteria for wonder is novelty, and so masses love the miracle worker.
The difference between unstable and dynamic. Between strange and eccentric. Between stubborn and consistent. Between reckless and courageous.
Sadly, in the mind of most, success.
I’ve heard that the definition of insanity is repeating the same action and expecting different results.
I would say simple-mindedness is to believe that anything can be repeated.
And if it can, it likely gives different results.
We may wish for unlimited resources, but must be realistic about the limits before us. There is no doubt- the educational branch of government is limited in its funding, and money going into special education is at the expense of money going into standard education. It might be worthy, it might not. But what one gains another loses. Fact.
The purpose of the prison system is to segregate criminals of the law from the rest of the herd. Recuperation? Secondary.
This may be for the benefit of the prisoners. Some healing looks a lot like brain surgery.
I would harm you, but then I would have to forgive you.
For fools, most of the world that is, supply creates demand. It is why they buy the newest smartphone and still stay losers.
I find it incredibly hard to respect people with smartphones, and near impossible to respect someone with Facebook.
I have a ‘don’t ask, don’t tell policy’.
Is it politically correct to blame addicts for ignoring the warnings?
Is it just correct?
The survivor fallacy: I seem to lose only individual socks, but no full pairs.
We are as naïve as we were a millennium ago, says Shaw. Worse, we think we are smarter, and this leaves us one mark behind.
I am vegetarian, pro-choice and consistent. I eat eggs and cow fetus.
Yum!
If you don’t believe in spirits and demons you’re a heretic; if you see them you are mentally ill.
Mosquito repellent manufacturers breed mosquitoes.
An atomic war between the USA and the USSR would have changed the course of history, would it not have? And still people believe that science (a human activity!) is deterministic in a meaningful way.
Don’t listen to the cry of denial, most women love being objectified.
Men too.
Alternative medicine is the only alternative to a corrupted system that treats painkilling as its main goal, with health secondary.
It’s not a very good alternative though…
The early bird catches the worm. Alternatively, the really, really, late bird from yesterday does.
Celebrities are just like us, but with a lot more people that care what they do and don’t care about them.
Like foreigners with guns.
I would (I pray) choose pain over vice, as I value virtue more than pleasure. But I still would wish pain on the sinners. I want them to recognize their own suffering.
Conversely- I feel less of a need to wish pleasure to the virtuous- as I know virtue is worthy of itself.
Interestingly- I seem only to want to increase pain in the world. What?!
A victim is not a sacrifice. Sometimes there is no higher good. Just a sunk-cost, a tragedy.
If you think cat roadkill is a tragedy, you are about as deep as a bowl of chicken soup.
You are also about as thoughtful as a tomato.
You are simply apathetic to the suffering of your fellow brothers and sisters, and think you can cover the blemish of your soul with tears shed over a feline.
Kill the pandas! Save human dignity!
Some people cannot be convinced of anything new.
Many people cannot be convinced of anything old.
The Confirmation Bias demands of an honest man to look for counter examples.
Those who mourn pandas should go visit third-world countries.
The Ba’al Shem
Chassidic Wisdom
A fallacy: G-d expressed his will through his Word, therefore to be intimate with his Word is to be intimate with G-d.
Only a holy man’s irreverence is a lesson on true holiness; A military man’s language reveals nothing of his mood.
For every good intention- make sure to take action, even the smallest.
The fire that burns is the fire that cooks. The passions that can destroy a man are the ones that give him life. The secret is to stay at the right distance.
I do not need to deny miracle men their powers in order to fight them. I simply proclaim a different truth: their powers come from Satan.
Change what you desire- and be magnificent.
Nothing in excess- including moderation.
All fables allude to you to some degree.
The Hasidic masters knew- everything is a lesson that is trying to teach you.
A rebellious nature and a submissive nature can both be sanctified if they are utilized at the right moments.
Perhaps we are so biologically molded that we must feel fear, love, hate, boredom etc. The only control is what the object of our impulses are.
Sometimes the truth of the story is not as important as its message- its relevance.
When coming to pray one may ask- ‘Who is G-d?’ Or one may ask ‘Who am I?’
And I don’t know which question is holier.
The love of life creates love of G-d.
Anger is a common cause of sin, but not necessarily a sin in itself.
Survival is a word of those concerned with tomorrow. Holy is a word of those concerned with today. To be in G-d’s favor is of ultimate importance, and all that exists is the fleeting now.
How one does is often more important than what one does.
Or: quality of your actions is often more important than what your actions are.
Deeper yet: what is going on in your head can be more critical than the banality of what your hands are doing.
That I shall be angry one day in the future is an inevitable reality. At what shall I be angry at?
When told of the new railways in Vienna, the Rebbe of Kotzk exclaimed: What’s this madness to hurry always!?
A story is told that one of the Hassidic Rebbes was at a banquet where a jester was performing. This jester was an expert at imitation, and would imitate all of the people around him to the pleasure of his audience. After requesting permission from him, the jester also imitated the Rebbe. The Rebbe broke out in tears at the end of the short performance, exclaiming: “Perhaps I do nothing but imitate the me of yesterday, just as this jester does!”
The Rebbe of Kotzk cried: I want you not to sin because you will be too busy with your holy toil!
A chassid came to the R’ of Kozk complaining that other chassids come back from their Rebbe high on spirituality, and he comes back from visiting the Rebbe only depressed and with feelings of worthlessness. The Rebbe of Kotzk responded: “And who said G-d wants you to feel spiritual. Perhaps he wants your tears?”
A saint waits for an opportunity to sacrifice the lower for the higher, as lovers wish for their love to be tested, so that they may prove their faith.
The duality of body and soul that has been impressed on us since birth makes us unable to conceive the greatness of King David, and why Isaac cared for the taste of game.
I love parables that are born as empty shells, waiting for the reality that matches them to become one with.
The question to ask before eating is “to what end?”
Shall my body be nourished or injured?
Shall my soul be cleaned or tainted?
It is not a question of defending G-d from the philosophical attack of evil in the world as it is to make sure that we are loved by at least someone. Hence the suffering becomes a rod of love from above.
The enlightened man is always at balance. Nothing can move him from his chair of vapor.
To be balanced at all times does not mean that one constantly plays with the scales. If the scales are made of iron, still, the weight of the mountains would break them. The balanced man has scales with holes in them. Nothing can push down on him at all.
Therefore- rather than trying run around like a madman finding weights to equalize the sides of the scales, work diligently to puncture holes in the scales. First you will see that water cannot be held in them, and eventually nothing at all.
There is something beautiful in ugly, and something ugly in beauty.
There is nothing in something, and something in nothing.
Sensing souls is an art, a skill. And seeing one’s own soul included as part of the same category.
Reality as words spoken by the creator. Listen to the soul.
Charles Darwin
Evolutionary Narratives
A hypothesis on why intelligent life has never contacted us. (Perhaps I am being overly naïve in paralleling humanity to other possible intelligences.)
Any society that has technological progress has conflict. The weaker in power (relative to the will) will attempt through novelty to gain the advantage. So a species that has technological progress will not be one devoid of war. Because technological progress eventually explodes when communication barriers are breached the rate of progress becomes one where the new is not integrated into the species ecosystem in a way that the society can certainly survive with. Example: if fire was to be fatal to humans, its spreading would be naturally stopped. But if cellphones are one-hundred-percent cancerous (with exposure of 30 years let’s say), the technological society will all die out. There is not enough time to test things properly.
Now, with war as part of the picture, and it seems inevitable that it should happen at one point or another, (time-line statistics as opposed to static statistics), we are likely to commit species-suicide.
In conclusion: intelligence will kill itself out (and take most of the planet with it) before being able to visit far off life of other planets.
That G-d’s divine plan demands that utility births virtue does not mean that utility is equal to virtue. Possessiveness birthed sharing, and clearly these stand as antipodes.
How many generations of selected breeding would be required to make man of chimpanzees?
Reverse: How many would be required to make chimpanzees of man?
Survival of the fittest in philosophy: those relevant to the next generation, not the deepest insights of the present.
Can we leave? Can we just go somewhere else where other humans haven’t messed it all up?
But how would we recognize the failure of modernity if not for our heritage?
We need an escape, but we need to bring the good things with us.
A sacrifice is always demanded for anything worthwhile.
The agenda of progressive is to forget the past and burn the records. But the past is not leaving us. There is a barbarian, an ape and a worm in everybody. Ignorance will not kill them.
Perhaps the mystical-like high of being a rebel can be explained in Darwinist terms. The top of the hierarchy gives orders, the bottom takes it. When we hear orders and rebel- but nevertheless don’t get our heads beaten into the ground until they are a pulp of bloody flesh and bone- our instinctual joy is awakened. Rebelling against society’s metaphorical orders is like moving up the social ladder. (If this analysis holds true, this should lead to the appeal of rebellion in men, and the appeal of rebels in women.)
Hunger begets aggression and/or flattery. To be assertive, one must feel no threat on life.
Do the hunger fads of modern fashion increase the sexual drive of women looking for a male to sustain them? If so… a very vicious cycle.
That a man began as ape is of no consequence. The question is to where will he go?
I know enough about evolution to know that I know nothing of evolution.
The steeple of being may be better in a different will than in the will to survive. That is, indirect achievement can be more successful than direct. Is there a man more famous than Moses, Socrates, Jesus, Buddha, or Mohammed? Can we have fun on purpose?
The cultured limit their own population by promotion of values like monogamy and chastity. This would be a failure in naïve Darwinian minds. Yet lions reproduce less than rats. The elite are intrinsically elite.
A satyr’s bottom half is a goat, like most people’s whole personality. But even the top half, human, like the best of humanity, still has horns that are used for battles of status and sex.
It seems that in Darwinist thought, to surrender is to feign weakness in order to escape, as wolves are not commonly taking prisoners. If so, then only corner your enemy completely if you want them to fight ferociously.
The weak is strong in that he needs invention, and necessity is a pretty decent mother.
We are often playing a massive game of the prisoners’ dilemma- and always choosing to betray. We only betray ourselves.
Sheep always outnumber the wolves.
Heuristic: If you can identify with the masses, you are a sheep.
The Alters of Musar
Living Right
To be a kvetch seems to be one of the universally accepted vices.
We do not like being told which of our sins brought which calamities into the world, but we don’t mind hearing which of our good deeds brings blessing.
The vast variety of opinions that I hear on how to live makes me so confused at the moments that I see the contradiction between them. But on regular days I see no problem with the eclectic inconsistent mix.
I find that I don’t follow my own advice as well as I expect myself to have.
Pride in a true virtue of oneself is a virtue. But pride in a mistaken attribute is repulsive.
To paraphrase Rebbe Nachman: This world is like a narrow bridge, on both sides a fall one thousand miles.
A tragedy should affect your appetite.
Everyone should write a list of virtuous reminders to be read every day.
Adolf Eichmann
Moral Trepidation
The first step to being a saint is to think in terms of morality. The details of moral knowledge are secondary.
Opportunity makes the thief, but she needed a partner like Poverty or Evil to conceive.
There is an abusive personality- but also a personality that creates, supports and sustains those abusive personalities. They always get off the hook.
A thought experiment: Imagine if every virtuous act was immediately rewarded with pleasure, and every vicious act with pain.
We would all be Virtue Automatons.
But what else is education? It seems that the complexity of a human is a precondition.
It seems that fatalism is more of a moral stance than an empirical one.
We must admit the moral problem that a candy bar is worth money, and money can save lives. Therefore: x candy bars = y lives.
Those excellent, divine people with sins and those wretched, evil with a good deed frustrate me.
The grey is acceptable, but mostly to be good or evil, with a salient and extreme exception is difficult to digest.
A riddle: If the saint renounced worldly pleasures to save his soul, why does he still give you bread?
It is all too common a trait of the cruel to care for the abstract ‘people.’
To love the minority for minority’s sake is…
It is incredible to note the difference between what a salesman thinks is ethical and what everyone else does.
If determinism can excuse the criminal, surely it can excuse the judge.
Awareness and memory are twins, whose union births virtue. Or in other words, thoughtless living is sin.
The best act is spoiled by a rotten motive; delicious shepherds’ pie is ruined by containing pieces of actual shepherds.
The noblest motive is ruined by a destructive action; or is it?
I don’t know.
If we told a cannibal that eating human flesh is wrong, he would not understand.
So too there are laws of a higher morality that are not understood by the non-cannibals.
Sometimes a person can be intellectually great yet still morally immature.
The story of the victim is often not a story at all. They were in many cases passive. It is the story of the criminal of which we have much to learn from. How terrible man can be!
Man plans, G-d laughs.
Man acts, G-d judges.
The most profound words pale in comparison with the simplicity of the pure actions.
The title of philosophy is irrelevant. Does it make me a better man?
Not thinking of the other- indifference- is the source of most evils from most men.
It is hard to think of ethics, not because of the intellectual aspect, but because it demands of your body and heart to live up to your mind.
To love one’s own virtue is a blessing, but it is also a form of blindness.
Those that blame others for failing are often just as susceptible to the same misdeeds, but are saved by chance. Those that are truly nobler understand failure, and only blame the others for not avoiding the potential failure.
It is no contradiction to be a fool and evil.
‘Moral luck’ is a cursed knowledge.
To do good does not mean the same as to feel the spiritual high of meditation. Sometimes the good is bitter.
Faceless people make much better victims.
It is important when studying history to remember that we have yet to kill Satan.
Humanity seems so insignificant when meditated upon. But cruelty still seems so cruel.
Oh, No! Another paradox!
Indifference allows more crime than a rallying cry for evil. It is easier to fight a Goliath than a whisper.
It is not the failure in temptation that is so contemptible and worthy of remorse, but allowing yourself to be in a position to fail.
If you have a dilemma if your action is immoral or neutral- it is immoral.
It is no contradiction to be weak-willed and evil.
The greatest lie is that we are good people. Certainly if we hold ourselves to the standards we hold others to.
The banality of evil makes us all into lucky Eichmanns and Eichman into one of us. How miserable can knowledge be!
No wonder Koheleth taught us that to increase wisdom is to increase anger. There are too many toxic truths for a man to be able to swallow without being poisoned.
I fear my goodness comes from weakness and not from strength. And my weakness covers her naked body in shame. And my mind dares not look at her. The consequence would be horrible self-knowledge, and even worse: knowledge of my fellow.
Who knew virtue could be so much fun?
When unsure how to help humanity, do some housework ya lazy bum!
Self-examination is as scary as rats running up trousers.
Democratic Man
The Environment
Philosophy is the alternative to being a complete product of your surroundings.
When culture is king- what somebody else thinks is more important than what you think.
Arrogance in one place is etiquette in another.
People who care what everybody thinks about them have a hard time imagining that there are people who couldn’t care less what they think.
If we are numbers for 12 years of our lives, and for the socio-economic elite for 20 years of our lives, how can we be expected to be outraged by the metrics that abuse us?
From the Sufis- You are a prisoner to any man who you wish to find favor in their eyes. Choose your jailers wisely.
There is no food I hate, because I can always avoid eating it. If only people were equally avoidable.
If peer pressure doesn’t scare you, you are either blind to its power, or don’t care about your authenticity.
Any psychological phenomena that affects seventy percent of the population affects you with a base rate of seventy percent.
It doesn’t have to be perfect logic in order for you to get the point.
Like saltwater, vanities and virtues make you thirsty for more of their kind.
Put all the most dignified men in a classroom and they will act like children.
I want to live in a place where dropping the name of an A-class celebrity and assuming everyone knows them is treated the same as if one mentioned the name of a pornographer.
The uniformity of clothing would not be depressing were it not an attempt at superficial individuality.
The designers know it, but the commoner is deaf to the blaring sirens. You are not as free as you feel.
Society is one big assembly line- what is the product?
If people knew how marketers are taught to manipulate the average consumer, and with what skill they do so, they would search for a way to resist. But if we wait a generation or two, the manipulation will be so commonplace, that our dignity will have been shrunk to the size of a mushroom.
Hearing arguments about which economic system is better is reminiscent of watching two men fighting over the better soccer team. I don’t care. The question is too narrow and dumb. Let us ask if any economical system matters- and if so how and in what way.
Utility equals money in the sense that merchandisable utility equals money.
And merchandisable utility has much more to do with the appearance of utility than with actual fulfillment of a purchaser’s needs.
Example: a proverb or joke is a utility that is non-merchandisable. So no financial compensation for the wisdom, wit, and joy given to the world.
A fashion product is worth its money- but the need itself was manufactured!
John Holt
Schools
The role of the teacher: to expose the student to viral information, and train the immune system. In the common tongue: the student should leave with a highly refined bullshit detector.
Three types of teachers; Those inspired by their teachers, those who come to fix the system, and those who can’t get a better job.
Riddle me this: to which category do the majority of teachers fall in?
The cure for gossip in the teachers’ room is the presence of a loose tongued student.
No one has ever tried to convince my wife that homeschooling is a bad choice by arguing: “School is so good! You learn so much there! There is no system more effective for creating intelligent thoughtful people!”
A pathetic observation: Most teacher’s feel uncomfortable at having their students question and challenge their teaching methods. Even professors at a teacher’s college. They would rather the student be silent and obedient like a mute, neutered dog.
Neil Postman is not the great education reformer I wish he was because his reform required a quality level of teachers that is all too rare.
A heuristic: College professors are the ones that were successful at school and too scared to go into the risky real life; those that hate failure to the core.
My potency as a teacher would be greatly enhanced if I was rich, and exponentially so if I had served time in jail for an act of revenge. So… what do students value?
The teacher, standing in front of 30 students, controls all the flow. If anybody spoke and manipulated words as the teacher does, directing the stream of thought to their planned ends- they would quickly be resented and left to themselves.
Upon experience, untrue. It seems we’ve been well trained.
Every human should have the right to not be taught under coercion. Similarly, every teacher should have the right not to teach.
“I don’t like you. I don’t want to teach you.”
Nothing like a homework assignment on the Holocaust to completely kill all the humanity in you.
Nothing is important on a multiple choice test.
I feel like a hook is in my skin when I think that sending kids to a place they don’t want to go to, to learn things they don’t want to do is considered natural, even when alternatives are wide open.
I love hearing about non-frontal teaching in frontal classes.
A totalitarian teacher. If not from me- Thou shall not know!
Common knowledge that everyone hates Shakespeare.
A tax-funded public babysitter service: School.
The end of education is the independence of the student. Liberate him by forcing him to practice liberty.
Design your students’ education to encourage questions rather than knowledge.
I would demand of schools to teach things of importance if I wasn’t convinced that they would botch the job up, and damage more than help.
It is easier to change the curriculum to match the test, than to admit that the test fails to measure the immeasurable.
Shouldn’t schools at the very least teach us how to read a contract, something that everybody does often in their lives?
Hush! The students shall answer each other.
We learn despite the classroom.
The education system fails to teach us of our lawful rights and duties. This means that society is built upon the utility of secretive lawyers who have an interest to make their expertise inaccessible to the masses. The power given to bureaucracy is immense. And all suffer but the men who can pay for others to do their paperwork.
Imagine the curriculum diversity if all homeschooled. There would be different focuses, on business, arts, sciences and all the other Platonized categories. There would be interdisciplinary galore! Finally, history and academic politics can be taught together.
Now what would be common? How to fix household appliances, how to fill out taxes, how to cook and be healthy. Most things that are not learnt past a first-grade level.
If we could burn down the schools and just make a completely voluntary learning center offering private and public classes the parents might finally take their kids' future seriously.
The more I am revealed of Academia the less I respect her. She cares more of style than content, and her style is bland, dry and boring.
Although the disillusionment happened in a not-so-highly-rated college (understatement!), I have read the works of Ivy League Universities as well. There is a correlation between intelligence and degrees, but probably not a causational one.
Also- a Ph.D. is no guarantee of somebody not being an imbecile, no matter where they got the degree from.
Mandatory school is similar to house arrest. I wonder if the gates of the school are to keep others out or the students in.
The bigger crime: monopolization of children by schools, or monopolization of knowledge? (Naturally, not of knowledge, but of all credentials that mean anything.)
If the goal of education is to give tools to students then it is incompatible to also demand all students succeed in everything. Unless of course the tools you are giving are so banal that anybody can acquire them. Or maybe you think everybody is the same.
The most important topic in formal education is the grading system.
I am constantly reminded that academics is an art of submission, not one of thought.
Isn’t it interesting that kids can’t go to college? And if you’re poor you can’t afford not to work at the age when the rich are in college? And that no one realized that you could teach intellectual jobs starting at age 14 and by 19 they would be professionals.
Why can’t kids go to programming courses and law school at 14?
Because then the rich would lose them riches.
Cheating on academic tests would be ridiculous if the test checked the student’s competence in the field. Surely, the student would be lacking something important that would make them seem like fools. Because this is not the reality we must wonder to ourselves how unethical cheating is, seeing that the academies are the biggest cheaters.
Education is a vehicle for cultivating humans. What is your end is the critical question. But the media is the message.
If schools only claimed to give professional skills, and no character development at all whatsoever- families may finally wake up.
If you want to kill the joy of learning anything-give a written test on it.
Vocabulary taught at schools should teach important words like reification, bias, peer pressure, etc. Not flashy words like malignant and bamboozle.
If there is truly a correlation between school and life than the idea of making test accommodations for the learning disabled is absurd.
All doing is learning. What are we doing in school?
What educators call ‘higher-order thinking’ the rest of the world just calls thinking.
Most of school is a cruel and boring game of ‘Guess what the teacher is thinking’.
And never, ever, second guess if what the teacher is thinking is actually true.
The whole western world goes through a very similar first twenty something years of their lives in institutions nearly identical from Japan to New York.
And yet they praise diversity! As if diversity was in the color of the skin! Diversity is in significantly differentiated backgrounds of thought!
Some stuck-up-professor-type felt threatened when a mechanic or handyman fixed something he couldn’t begin to even diagnose. Thus the concept ‘good hands’ created. A good mind, my friend, and better than yours.
No uneducated- only educated by the rabble.
In a classroom- I feel like a wolf in the zoo. Caged, Sedated. But frustrated and edgy.
A wild wolf, now captured, knows in every heartbeat the difference between freedom and captivity. But those born in the zoo don’t notice that they don’t chase their prey, and dine on pizza and sushi given from the hands of their slave drivers. I wish to howl in the classroom the cry of freedom. Know! There is freedom and it doesn’t look like this. There is education and passion in the hunt for knowledge and awakening- and this is certainly not it. AWAKE!
But even the most ferocious beasts born in captivity and raised with a stick and carrot become deaf.
Why should I hurt myself to rebel against propagandist education? Those wise enough will avoid it, those not will be none the wiser. –An indecent excuse.
Neil Postman
Modern Media
We must know what is happening on the other side of the earth, but we are too scared to look into our own soul. Who is ignorant of reality?
The more power society has, the less the individual has. Consequently, to empower the individual we must weaken the grasp of society.
The larger the quantity of people in a society, the stronger the society is. Consequently, to empower the individual we must fragment society.
The greater the tools of communication are, the more people can connect into one society. Consequently, to empower the individual we must deny the right of mass communication.
To always be updated is to forget how to remember.
When all becomes unexpected, the sense of wonder is lost, and all that is left are the base desires.
The speed of information is the speed of deception, mistakes, irrelevancies and mind-waste, plus the time to filter.
Aesthetics of a poem blind you to the message that infiltrates your mind. The comfort of the video numbs you to the injection of passivity and waste I become.
The children-adult line is getting blurred, but I only see the adult losing their virtues, and the children learning vices.
The ideology of consumerism is so overwhelmingly bought that the mere idea of making public advertising illegal seems bizarre.
If they don’t encourage you to slow down, stop and think, then they are manipulating you.
Does media literacy help one act, or only talk better?
A narrative is what makes us human. But the metric machine is a hungry predator for living flesh.
Electronic communications have severed the ability to communicate by offering false alternatives to real connection.
If you do not have enough information to justify forgetting you cannot have a proper hierarchy of value of information.
Social media gives one loneliness without the benefits of being alone.
How empty must your life be that you constantly consume entertainment created for the millions? So empty that complete passivity is an integral part of your life, and the thought of its lack makes you sad? Your life is empty my friend, but with effort you can fill it.
A teenager is the perfect target for advertising. Not because he is dumb- but because all of his money is spent on luxuries while Papa and Mama take care of shelter and food. And a young mind once molded is forever static in the world of consumerism.
Where would they learn otherwise?
Popular media is quite like cinnamon; all spice, no substance, and damaging to ingest in large quantities.
The cruelty of the industrial/electronic age is like an abusive parent, who creates a personality flaw in the child by abusing their nature and implanting a love for the abuse.
A chat room is like sitting around a big table where nobody is listening to each other, everybody is screaming, and your opinion is unimportant.
Intelligent and stupid stand on the same spectrum. If we admit that certain activities make one intelligent, then the lack of them makes one stupid.
People who watch TV are stupid.
A computer that comes with ads is a corruption.
Dear me! This exists!
I would diagnose that fantasy entertainment such as fluff novels and Hollywood films let us experience life from the perspective of the protagonist. When the credits roll we are left with the bland, miserable self (who has just burned their life away with crappy literature or videos). Who wouldn’t want to escape to the superhero self on the screen?
I am blessed with an awareness that won’t let me believe I am the man on the screen. Even when watching I am jealous- so I curse him and press off.
People pose for pictures, even candids. Yet we will buy a newspaper that is completely at ease with lying to our faces in order to influence us to consume products just to make a buck for themselves.
Ironically, this is how we ‘know’ what is going on in the world.
Everyone with Facebook has more friends and is better liked than me.
Rappers harm blacks more than the KKK.
Braces reached the tipping point and is now standard. Beware, soon come more forms of cosmetic surgery.
Theodore Kaczynski
Technology, About and Against
The most valuable tools are tool-making tools.
It is interesting to imagine how technologies introduced into a society would have played out differently in other alternative realities. What would the internet look like if there was never television? What would machine guns do to Napoleon’s France?
Technologies are creators of content and molders of people. But remember, they enter an ecosystem. What is already there is critical in understanding the way the technology plays out.
The mixture of knowledge in a medium of folly confuses. Like wine in a bedpan.
Sometimes necessity is the mother of invention and sometimes invention is the mother of necessity. In general, life is full of bi-directional incestuous relationships of this kind. Think mind-body causality.
I do not know if I should be joyous or mournful when I read that the same faults that we have in modern times existed as well long ago. For example: recently I read Montaigne complain that men will readily believe printed words more than spoken. Mournful: because it makes it seem like we have not improved ourselves. Joyous: perhaps we have not made ourselves much worse either.
We are the products of our products. Innovate with care.
Guinea pigs are a moral experiment subject when the alternative is homo sapien.
We would mock a title like Level 45 Husband, but don’t mind an IQ of 145. Why? Because intuition understands that relationships cannot be quantified, but is not smart enough to intuit about intelligence.
Reflection, thankfully, is good enough to realize that quantifying intelligence is balderdash. There are smarter and stupider, but as Boring has wonderfully put it: “The test tests what the test tests.”
I fear a day that Level 45 Husband might be commonplace.
We are progressing to a point where all discomfort, physical or psychological, will disappear. And I warn- without trials, what is the worth of man!
Imagine a book titled “The Greatest Novel You Ever Read”. A book created with AI to meet your every demand- including surprise.
Not nearly as frightening as a video made in such a fashion.
Progress and change are not the same. However, ‘progressives’ are pretty much pro-any change.
The word post-modern is filled with the foolish arrogance of neomania.
Are my frustrations at the bureaucratic world because of my incompetence or is it an intrinsic aspect of a system that requires details without responsibility?
Like Actaeon, when man is too clever for his own good, the tools that served devour him. Maimonides tells us that natural sciences, like philosophy, are to be hidden from the masses.
Finding an oasis in the desert is finding a human, non-bureaucratic response to your email. Thank you Nathan.
Having a celebrity as the background of your phone reeks of idolatry; of yourself- narcissism.
Cars created the streets, the urbanization and employment of our age. They stole the freedom of transportation by forcing us to go into eternal exile and has made wandering Jews of the whole industrialized world. And we were blind when they came to banish us of the land. And we stay blind and hardly feel our loss.
It’s very hard to be an ethical person when most of your own world is out of your control. I can’t produce my own clothing, food or shelter without a drastic change.
Perhaps being ethical demands drastic changes and sacrifices?
When you say it like that…
Tetris-playing zombies are the backbone of our modern economy.
Backwards people are technologically primitive. They do not have the tools.
Progressive people are intellectually primitive. They create tools without reason, not seeing the dreadful side effects.
Two-thousand years from now, if we survive, we will be seen as the Backwards-Progressives, on all accounts primitive.
We pray the genetically enhanced humans will hate their womb and not spread the disease. Otherwise, let us pray that they are egotists and keep the curse to themselves.
When Richard Nisbett tells us of a new method like A/B testing, he presents it like a benign and positive tool, much the way the military would present the latest tool for death and pain as a win for the civilian.
How can a man be an individual if he is never alone? And so our handheld social media kills our sparks of divinity.
I like the word neomania because it implies madness.
I like the word technophile because it nuances a sexual sickness.
The title ‘Science’ gives the impression of ethical neutrality and positive intellectual achievement. The ethical neutrality is worth reconsidering. Pasteurization is a distinctly positive ethical human achievement. Similarly, immunization.
But are gas chambers and torture techniques ethically neutral? The desire to acquire such knowledge is in itself evil.
Perhaps one would call these technologies and not sciences. Very well, then let us apply the same critique to technologies and leave to science only mathematics and physics. (But what about the Atomic Bomb!?)
Of course, the context is critical in deciding whether a scientific/technological intellectual/practical endeavor is ethical. Stanley Milgram’s experiments would have been heinous crimes were they to have been done by the Hitlerists or Stalinists. But as a call to greater self-awareness of the pathetic slave inside us all it is a virtue.
And for huge corporations to be collecting gregarious amounts of data to predict how we behave in order to utilize (manipulate our behavior into their dollars) users (the used?) is not an ethically neutral question that can be brushed under the rug of science.
Dinosaurs evolved by breeding bigger, until their size caused their extinction. Men evolved by breeding smarter, until…
Nassim Nicholas Taleb
Antifragility, Lindy and More
“Realistic long-term predictions” is an oxymoron.
I could pride myself in ignorance of the trivial. So I would never pride myself in ignorance of the history of mathematics or chemistry or any science. Nor would I pride myself in the ignorance of any science itself. I am not proud not to know anything of Far East history, philosophy, or even contemporary realities.
But I am proud not to know the multitude of ‘Here today, gone tomorrow’ fleeting trivialities. Even if one of them is important, I gain much by ignoring the hundreds of thousands.
A heuristic for judging someone’s wisdom: how well the lindy effect is presented in their personal library.
A lindy effect: The longer the dishes are in the sink, the longer they are likely to stay there.
Until a machine is antifragile, we should bow in humility to our creator.
When such an artificial creation is manufactured, we should bow in humility to the creator that made such an intelligent being.
Our education system encourages learning the ‘Hard’ sciences like math, physics, chemistry. It considers the humanities to be less in their rigor of critique. This inclination feeds itself. But in truth, hard sciences have a comparatively black and white world to the humanities. So the level of critique needed is much easier to acquire. The only real critique possible in the humanities seems to be Lindy (from the Lindy Effect). All that is considered critique is more like a social power game, nothing to do with rigor and reality based feedback.
Therefore, to understand something of human reality, make sure that the classics vastly outnumber the new in your intellectual consumption. (Ratio of 9 to 1 sounds like a good base line.)
Most people don’t give mind to known unknowns, even when they have trumpets and screams.
A bird will get confused and fall from the sky like a stone if she tries to explain how she flies.
There is an art in knowing when practical knowledge is all that matters, and when a theory is needed.
To create more extreme fluctuations reduce the amount of functions. One thousand different tracks playing at the same time will create a more constant noise than three.
When healthy-controlled damage, when sick- rest.
An intellectual should be judged as worthy if he has skin in the game, not if he is a non-conformist. It is possible, after all, that one truly believes the majority to be right.
We are all so intelligent in words- because our fanciful ideas never bite us.
People are not nearly as scared of centralizing as I am. Thank you Taleb, for making me see the disaster in everything.
It is an intellectual blunder to defend an institution by appealing to external factors and tying them together.
Example: Do not say that you are pro-democracy/anti-fascist because of the humanitarian ideology inherent in them. We know of democratic institutions that were not humanitarian at all, and of monarchies that were humanitarian.
Either say that:
A-You are humanitarian and at the time being democracy seems best for such an ideal.
B-You are humanitarian and democracy in general seems best for such an ideal, and therefore even if now it is not working out, you believe that the democratic system should be kept for future times.
C-You are humanitarian, and will prefer any form of government that is humanitarian, be it democracy or a tyranny.
However, the masses will be more honest in the following:
D- You are pro-democratic regardless of the humanitarian aspect, but the thought of inherent differences that is to be found in other governments makes you uncomfortable.
E-You are pro-democratic because it is in fashion.
F-You are pro-democratic because that is the status quo, and you are a conservative.
G- You are pro-democratic because it gives you power (perhaps illusionary, but beside the point) and any other form of government or lack thereof (monarchic, oligarchic, anarchic, etc.) may deny you said power.
A system has a great advantage over its rival if it is easy to fix when broken. For example: even if more fragile, a car with fewer pieces is better, as diagnosis and therapy are easily practiced.
The internet of things seems like they want everybody to be completely dependent on the good grace of luck.
The biggest problem of the agency problem is that the agents change the meaning of words and therefore alter our conception of reality. Parents care about grades because of teachers- instead of education. Education becomes getting good grades.
The problem with agents is that they have the appearance of success as their goal, as opposed to their employers, that need real success. If we got rid of agents in education, parents would quickly discover which skills and knowledge are worthy of teaching. Hence, the dissolution of the school system would only raise the quality of the students.
The new diverse system would be anti-fragile.
It does matter if the people controlling the school system have an evil agenda but even a benevolent one and a mistake is disastrous. Over centralization is the bane of it all.
In other words: Home-schooling is the decentralization of child control and allows (in almost all cases) for the children to be raised by people who certainly care for them and their future in all of life’s facets. (Solution to evil agendas)
A mistake that parents make will never be all reaching- and parents are much more dynamic because of lack of bureaucracy. (Minimizing the damage of mistakes and the chances of stagnant curriculum and pedagogical processes to survive)
Solution:
Step 1: Make schooling optional. In parallel allow homeschoolers drastic tax-cuts. Create learning centers (libraries and rooms for homeschoolers to use and collaborate with other parents and educators.)
Step 2: Demand opt-in for school. Status quo is no school.
Step 3: Privatize schools. No free schooling for anyone. Private schools should be highly taxed and considered a luxurious waste of money. Better to hire a private tutor.
Of course the economy will suffer in the beginning. Expect more education to be more valued in women. (They are your kid’s teacher!) Expect higher quality thinking people. Expect more stable family structures. Expect a slightly better world protected from mass propaganda. But expect some time to pass before the parents themselves realize what mindwaste they have ingested. (I say 10 years.)
The sad part is that most aggressive protesters will be teachers and parents. Teachers want their jobs. Parents don’t want responsibility- they prefer their jobs to their children.
Shel Silverstein
Madness
Mild depression can be temporarily cured by jumping up and down on one foot while screaming your favorite children’s rhyme.
When we praise children it is often to subtly criticize adults.
Meditating upon apes, I thought there was a negative correlation between hairiness and intelligence until I remembered fish and rocks.
When words are silent, poetry can speak.
Olympian gods and cartoon characters are both immortal, but a great gap divides the holy from the whimsical.
It is a bad job of raising a child if they can’t fall asleep on a pea with twenty mattresses between them.
One of the problems crazy people make for the sane is that they invoke jealousy.
Am I alone in feeling the doctor was reacting irresponsibly to the situation? By monkey number four, he should have called child services.
Tyler Durden
Destructive Souls
One of the most attractive compliments to a thinker is that the masses call him heretical. Keep this in mind when in search of great men.
Radical ideas frighten the mediocre at mere suggestion.
Greatness of a man is in proportion to his ability to suffer and acknowledge dissonance of thoughts. The magnificent is fragmented, like the word.
“Nobody was harmed,” but I still wouldn’t want it to have been me.
A doomsayer is at an advantage over the audience of his black prophecies because he is slightly comforted by the carnage with the knowledge that he was right.
I insult them so that I may fear to be one of them.
When you speak, he listens. He absorbs your words into his heart. But the man does not bow to your authority. He shatters your craft with an iron hammer.
Nihilism is often used to justify the evil and animal instinct unbridled. But it is at least as good a justification for good and divine actions.
The purpose of structure is the joy of destroying it.
A creator- that is what I want to be.
A destroyer- a perquisite for any artist.
The earlier a nuclear war, the more likely humanity will survive.
Some ideas are like a rhinoceros in a small ceramics store. They break everything, yet you are left with a feeling that what just happened is more absurd and humorous than tragic.
A grievance planted in fertile men can grow into an action of revolution.
Some people are like a piggy bank; they do nothing of value, hoard somebody else’s hard earned money, and everyone enjoys seeing their insides spread out.
Is the difference so great between the assassination of the CEO of a cigarette company and an enemy mercenary general?
Am I wrong when I think that there are some people I wouldn’t feel any urgency in performing CPR for?
The wicked look good ugly, bloody, and unconscious.
Curious George
The Learning Process
To ask is silver; to remember a question, gold.
To know the answer is common, to seek noble.
The art of asking a question is like planting a seed; with care the answer erodes, and sprouts new life that brings fruits- with more seeds to plant.
There is an art in knowing which question to ask first.
The best questions lead to questions on the assumptions of the former questions.
What is the most important question?
“What are the most important questions?”
Radical undermining of the currently held opinion can happen when you answer differently.
Radical undermining will almost always happen when you ask differently.
Choosing the question is the art of the wise. The crafty scoundrels will choose the questions for you, and mold your brain.
All the wrong questions with all the right answers kill the truth.
The text as a medium is one whose tempo is decided by the reader, and is constantly managed by him or her.
The lecture, or video- especially if presented before an audience of more than one- leaves all control to the presenter.
Hence- the text as a medium encourages creative (in the sense of autonomous) thinking, while those others encourage passivity and submission.
Now the riddle is solved why people are able to listen to Ivy League university level lectures and still be complete idiots.
There is teaching, and there is learning. And there often is no correlation between them.
Teaching in a deductive manner fools us into thinking that learning can be done in such a way.
You can learn much more in a street gang than in a school. Naturally the skills and information will be in a specific field. But education happens wherever there is professionalism.
You cannot learn how to do most things by simply observing. Except, perhaps, one may learn how to observe.
When one listens to a loud conversation on public transportation it is not eavesdropping. It is transforming a very irksome distraction into a psychological field observation.
To be a critical thinker one needs time to reflect. If the listener can just barely keep the pace with the speaker, then there is no room for any thought beyond the words said.
Either designate time to think on what you’ve heard, or have slow conversations.
I feel joy when a conviction of mine is proved wrong. It is like survival of the fittest thoughts in my mind. I am stronger from this growth.
But when I lose my memories of thoughts arbitrarily, from forgetfulness, lost papers, or accidentally deleted computer files, I am disheartened.
When those thoughts are written down, they can be reincarnated, and therefore grow, or be destroyed. Now, they lurk in the dark caves of my mind, affecting my schema of the world. Those captured creatures, were they to be in the light would be available for cultivation and slaughter.
How sensitive are we to the dissonance between what we think and what is?
A technique in learning.
As long as my ideas seem to recycle themselves, I know I am far from truth. Reality is too multi-faceted.
A man was searching for the biggest pit in the world. He figured it would be underground- so he began digging. Soon he discovered a small pit. Upon digging more and more- Lo and Behold! A great pit of mighty proportions.
So is discovering thoughts- we create them- but as we create we are working too hard to know it. Upon retrospect we think we have found what was always there.
It is legitimate to be foolish, but it is not legit to stay a fool. The paradox is that it requires much intelligence to know how to learn.
The horse pulling the carriage does not teach the passengers to walk.
Shana
Love, Friendship and Family
If not a token of love- likely a loan with interest.
‘I would love your attention on condition that I may ignore it.’
Women want attention from love. Men want status from love. But the noble want love itself.
If half of marriages end up in divorce we should probably be teaching children more social skills.
To love is to have all facets embrace another.
Prince Charming ain’t worth jack if he doesn’t wash the dishes with the same love he kills the dragon.
Love can be given and received but never taken.
Man is doomed to be half a man, or to be lonely.
Multiple outlets lower the strength of the current.
Othello will teach us the wretchedness of destroying friendship, and how destroying love is greater than destroying life.
Getting a life coach: I have no wise friends who care for me.
If your friend would hate you if you were evil, that friend is worth paying dearly for.
Not only chickens run around without heads. So does any man without a friend to critique him.
Listen closely to what you are praised for. Keep the friends who praise you for what you want to be.
Do you have none to rebuke you with love? Then you have no true friends.
How precious is the friend that knows how to hint to you your faults, not to tease you or inflate his ego, rather to gently chastise you so that you may improve!
What a blessing to have a friend to share your thoughts with.
I wish people so much greater than others would be incapable of being insulted by them. It is sad to see an angel hurt because ants don’t love them as they wish.
To see a friend suffer and not be able to help is torture.
Kind words are more soothing than hot coffee in the winter.
A pinch of aggressiveness would sever all my social connections. I am already so foreign from the blank faces of the goats. But I am dependent on their companionship and love. The heavens know if my timidity is a virtue or a vice.
You did not choose your name, but you can choose who to tell it to.
The successful people need to know that even when they are liked, the people that like them don’t like themselves for it.
The most successful businessmen and politicians probably have a family they don’t want to see.
I strongly suspect a correlation between wisdom and passive-aggressive character.
Why did Jacob not simply throw Leah to the dogs? He knew that once he had been with her she was ruined. But to keep her? She was hated by her husband.
And wicked Lavan knew he could count on Jacob to be nice. Kindness as an invitation to abuse.
Encouragement and nagging are distinguished by the will of the recipient.
The small voice chirps words of nonsense.
My heart cries from the beauty of my son’s speech.
The assembly line is the bane of our lives, and the only way to redeem it is to limit its use to the family units.
In ancient times the child was the parents’ responsibility and therefore their possession, even to be killed. Today the child is the state’s possession. What will it make of the children?
We encourage the love of people in the four corners of the earth. Can we encourage the love of people distant in time?
Everyone that does not have intense family politics should be grateful.
Paying for love degrades love, but some would mistake it for degrading money.
Regression to youth around family is about as common as mosquitoes and butt rash.
One mask is enough for even a multitude of hidden emotions.
Afterword
I
A prayer:
G-d,
Let these words bring good to the world for all your children,
Let true and false be slaves to good and evil,
Let this book be inspiration for men and women to be better today then yesterday.
G-d,
Let me accept that I will be misunderstood and thought a fool,
And understood and known a fool.
G-d,
Please bring our hearts to redemption, and through our breath redemption to your world.
II
(TO BE WRITTEN IMMEDIATELY BEFORE PUBLISHING)